Criminal Justice Ethics and Cultralperspectives

In: Other Topics

Submitted By terrijoe
Words 957
Pages 4

Miranda v. Arizona - 384 U.S. 436 (1966)

Ernesto Miranda, a 22 year old male, was accused of raping an 18 year old female in 1963. Upon his apprehension, Mr. Miranda was presented with a confession requiring his signature; Mr. Miranda underwent a police interrogation that was reported as spanning upwards of 2 hours – within his interrogation, he made a full confession, agreeing that he did so without duress, force, or threat. However, at no time was Mr. Miranda ever told about this right to council or his right to remain silent.
Prior Proceedings:
Mr. Miranda was charged with kidnapping Count I; and Rape, Count II; and pronounced guilty by the Superior Court, Maricopa County, Yale McFate, J., entered a judgment of guilty sentenced to serve from twenty to thirty years on each count, to run concurrently. (Arizona, 1965)
Vignera v. New York, the defendant made oral admissions to the police after interrogation in the afternoon, and then signed an exculpatory statement upon being questioned by an assistant district attorney later the same evening.
Westover v. United States, the defendant was handed over to the Federal Bureau of Investigation by local authorities after they had detained and interrogated him for a lengthy period, both at night and the following morning. After some two hours of questioning, the federal officers had obtained signed statements from the defendant
California v. Stewart, the local police held the defendant five days in the station and interrogated him on nine separate occasions before they secured his exculpatory statement.
State v. Miranda, 401 P.2d 721 (Ariz. 1965) (Arizona, 1965) in this appeal the defendant brought up several points of law: Rule 236, Rules of Criminal Procedure, 17 A.R.S. (1956); His case did not go to trial in a timely manner. He thought there were objectionable,…...

Similar Documents

Criminal Justice Ethics

...Criminal Justice Ethics Monica A. Stoddard Prof. Stephen Knights CRJ 410 June 10, 2012 Two of my most important values is integrity and honesty. Integrity and honesty go hand and hand. Without honesty there is no integrity. Integrity is doing the same thing whether you are in a group or completely alone; in other words, doing the right thing, all of the time, even if no one is watching.   Criminal justice integrity is especially important in police work. It is an essential value for officers to maintain even if they are trying to fit into the subculture of law enforcement. Much corruption in police departments has been the result of officers compromising integrity. These principles are important to me because as a criminal justice professional I am entrusted to do a job that may require little to no supervision. Another of my important values is honesty. Honesty is a very important part of our personal and professional lives. Being dishonest can break down relationships and harm the community as a whole. Honesty is also a major value in the criminal justice system. In order for the system to even work it must be based on honor and honesty. I will remain professional on and off duty. Some citizens have this idea that some criminal justice officials are crooked. Remaining professional while on duty is very important. No matter how an inmate or a probationer or parolee may act disrespectful, I must remain in control of the situation as to not get out of......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2

Criminal Justice Ethics

...Ethics in Criminal Justice Ethical Dilemma 1: Gun Rally After receiving a tip regarding a possible unlawful rally being planned, you must decide what the proper course of action is, taking into account your personal support of the mission of the rally, and your duties and obligations to uphold the law. The proper course of action in this scenario is to assign a subordinate officer to identify the leader or the organizers of the event, and inform them of all of the permit requirements, local ordinances, and laws of the municipality which pertain to public gatherings. Ethical Dilemma 2: Chief’s Orders A decision was made to advise other police officers about the anonymous tip. The chief officer on duty advises you to take certain actions which you believe are improper and biased; you are faced with the dilemma of obeying what appears to be an unlawful order. This scenario requires you to balance between following the order of a superior officer, and performing your own duties in accordance with the oath you took upon being sworn as a police officer. The proper course of action is to do both; follow the orders to the extent that the rally is not allowed, and perform your duty as a public servant. Ethical Dilemma 3 : Accepting Favors You discover that an officer from a neighboring police agency you are assigned to work with accepts gratuities on a regular basis; the officer justifies his actions, citing an “agreement” with members of the public. You are......

Words: 431 - Pages: 2

Criminal Justice Ethics

...asdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm CRIMINAL JUSTICE ETHICS Ethical & Legal Issues in Professions 6/2/2013 Crystal Lynn Hunt | Criminal Justice Ethics After reviewing the tutorial on criminal justice ethics, my answer on the case would have to be Report the incident to your supervisor. I choose this answer for the following reasons: 1. Partner did not use prudence when making the decision to interview the minors alone, with no parental contact and choosing not to videotape the interview/confession. Ethical decisions were not made while conducting the interview. 2. Honesty and justice for the teens were not being considered in the decision of my partner. 3. My job as a criminal investigator is to protect the community, respect the rights of others and serve justice to the victims. When the investigator decided to take actions into his own hands and interview the minors with no parent or guardian present and no video for evidence it not only jeopardized the case, the department as well as the community. Although the minors do have a criminal history they have the right to be treated fair and by the laws set in place to protect them until proven guilty by a judge. These rights were taken from them when the investigator did not follow department policies. Although it......

Words: 691 - Pages: 3

Criminal Justice Ethics

...govern the assembly of people for the purpose of holding a protest rally. A peaceful demonstration or assembly can be a productive way to express what we feel is wrong with our government. While such a protest is considered a part of our first amendment rights, most cities do require a permit in an effort to help avoid traffic and crowd problems. The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees individuals the right of freedom of assembly. Under the Common Law and modern statutes, however, the meeting of three or more persons may constitute an unlawful assembly if the persons have an illegal purpose or if their meeting will breach the public peace of the community. If they actually execute their purpose, they have committed the criminal offense of riot. Even as a police officer you strongly support Article 2 of the Constitution. Which includes "the right of the people to bear arms." The U.S. Supreme Court stated that the militia reference doesn't limit arms to only law enforcement and the military. Most Americans have a constitutional right to own guns for the purpose of self-defense or certain legal activities, such as hunting or target practice. The fact if a rally does not have a permit as a police officer you need to advise your fellow police officers about the anonymous tip you received. In conclusion, as a Police officer the correct decision would be to advise your fellow officers in your precent about the gun rally being held the next day without a......

Words: 686 - Pages: 3

Criminal Justice Ethics

...Criminal Justice Ethics Paper Ethics - 232 September 28, 2013 Criminal Justice Ethics Paper A few months ago, a woman was brutally raped, beaten and left for dead. Since the attack she remains in a coma. This case has risen to national prominence as an example of how today’s youth no longer respects fundamental social values, television and video game violence has desensitized young men to the consequences of crimes such as assault and rape, and as a demonstration of the inability of the police to keep the streets safe for law-abiding citizens. My partner and I work in the criminal justice system as police officers and handle most of the homicide cases in our area. The publicity from this crime has placed our police department under pressure to send someone to trial for this crime immediately. A gang of young men were spotted in the areas where the victim was found assaulting and threatening people that were passing by. Two members of the gang were arrested. The two members are both male and 14 years of age that both have previous records of robbery and assault. Our obligation as police officers is to follow the policy and ethical standards of our police department and the law, which states, minors must be informed of their legal right to have their parents present during the interrogation and to use videotape during important interviews. However, my partner has pushed his ethical obligation aside and interviews both of the minors while deciding not to contact......

Words: 608 - Pages: 3

Cja384 Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Cover (host, time, place): Ethics in Criminal Justice Attendees: Law enforcement officers, corrections officers, and professionals within the criminal justice profession. 5 areas of ethical conduct: 1. Proper use of professional and ethical authority It is common for criminal justice professionals to act beyond the limits of their authority. Proper training to help officers learn to control their actions and to uphold their reputation will reflect positively on the agency. 2. Racial Discrimination Both fellow employees and the community are affected by discrimination in law enforcement. Treating all individuals fairly and ethically will show proper professional behavior, and help them be a positive role model for the criminal justice system. 3. Bribes Unethical behavior included the acceptance of gifts for bribes from the community, agencies, criminals, or fellow co-workers in return for special treatment. 4. Honesty Trust is necessary for a positive professional relationship with the community. Immoral or deceiving actions cause a lack of trust in the criminal justice profession. Law enforcement officers are held to a higher ethical standard because of their role to keep the community safe. They take an oath of office, are expected to comply with professional code of ethics, and are subject to various laws, rules, and regulations (Gleason, 2006). 5. Excessive force Officers need to be able to think critically in stressful situations, and learn to......

Words: 561 - Pages: 3

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Understanding that a well know criminal is in the district does not negate the fact that he too, as a citizen, is protected by the law. "Police officers must uphold the law regardless of the offender's identity" (Pollock, 2013, p. 115). As an officer of the law, it is their duty to enforce the law and protect the community from crime ethically. In situation two, if a known criminal was the victim, I would know the ethical decision would be to treat this criminal's case as fairly as anyone else’s. After reading this incident, it reminded me a of a First 48 case where a suspected murderer was murdered. Despite knowing that the victim had killed a man and a woman, the detectives investigated his murder as they would do anyone else’s. The fact is that every crime has a criminal behind them. That criminal needs to be prosecuted in order to bring justice to the victim and to protect community. This criminal who stole the lawnmower may move on to steal from someone else, or even commit a larger crime. Although it may seem foolish to protect a criminal, the minor criminal is still a victim of a crime. I would not attempt to provide unfair service to the minor criminal during this incident, as that would compromise my integrity as an officer. By ignoring this crime, as an officer, I would give the community mixed signals about what I am there to do. I should send the signal that I am there to enforce the law at all times. However, this would not stop me from staying vigilant to......

Words: 331 - Pages: 2

Ethics of Criminal Justice

...intrinsically happy, but rather in a materialistic way that has restricted use or value. One holds happiness to be one of the highest desirable goods that one can feel in life. These two forms of goods share the same ultimate goal, but one can’t obtain the instrumental good without the intrinsic good. These two goods bring the ultimate happiness to one’s life. (Williams and Arrigo, p. 146) Intrinsic and instrumental goods share the same ultimate goal however, the difference between the two are visible. Intrinsic goods are things that bring happiness within us, as for instrumental goods are the things that are materialistic, and other categories such as honesty, and legal rights. For instant, the example of legal rights used in Ethics, Crime, and Criminal Justice by Christopher R. Williams on page 147 states, “It may be the case that having legal rights aids in producing a more just society in which people are better able to pursue good lives.” Legal rights is an instrumental good in which by having the society to be more just in which influences people’s lives to be better and desire to live a life that is morally good is what helps obtain and intrinsic good of happiness. These two go hand in hand when it comes to obtaining the ultimate happiness. At times, one faces certain situations in which things are diverted and take a turn to have a different outcome. These problems are brought up naturally in an everyday life situation, in which in this example, legal rights can......

Words: 1204 - Pages: 5

The Criminal Justice Administration Analysis and Ethics

...The criminal justice Administration Analysis and ethics 484 4/20/2015 Dwayne Carr The criminal justice Administration Analysis and ethics Professional conduct and ethics are essential pieces, to the criminal justice administrations with ethics is defined what a person moral beliefs is right from wrong. The criminal justice administrations have to deal with a problem that are ethical on a daily basis and have to handle the ethical situation in behavior that is professional. The criminal justice administration and the law enforcement administration have a terrible time with professional conduct, and ethic’s particular matters might be hard to take on for the reason. Because of administration of criminal justice have a duty of creating moral decisions of what counts as right or wrong makes them have to be very professional. Also, employ critical thinking skill as well. Within this paper, it will analysis discuss, the critical thinking with the concerning association with ethics. In addition, professional conduct role with police officers, as well as the five areas of the ethical conduct, should communicate within the seminar. Also the reason to choice those areas and the suppose benefits, with the training for each the public and law enforcement. Professional Code of Ethic for Law Enforcement With the professional organization, concerning with certain parts of the law, medicine, also the criminal justice system as......

Words: 1288 - Pages: 6

Criminal Justice Ethics

...Brooke Fritz Mini-Paper CCJS 380 5055 Ethical Behavior in Criminal Justice 3/24/15 Ethics Ethics is a very important subject that requires a lot of focus and attention in the criminal justice field. Police integrity and ethics is a crucial element to an efficient police agency. In every police agency, it is desired to have an environment which has effective partnerships between the police and citizens. Good ethics and integrity is so important because it is what builds trust within a community. Police leadership must be in the highest ethical standards if the agency wants to keep the public’s trust. In order to be successful at enhancing integrity and ethics within an organization, leaders must establish consistent ethical mentoring and role modeling. It only takes one single incident of unethical behavior to turn an admired police agency into one of the least-respected. Ethics is known to be the foundation of the criminal justice system. Ethics is what has developed the moral reasoning we use, how we define criminal activity, and what the society considers acceptable punishment. Ethics must be studied because the criminal justice system is the most effective and best operates in an ethical manner. It is important that we study ethics in criminal justice so that we know what should be done in different given situations. Ethics entitles doing the right thing, at the right time, for the right reason. That raises a common question, how are we supposed to know......

Words: 346 - Pages: 2

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...grade for the work submitted or for the entire course, and may result in academic dismissal. | | | |CJ7011-8 |Gabriele Suboch | | | | |Ethics and Criminal Justice |Assess a Case Scenario to Foster a Culture of Ethics | | | | Faculty Use Only Running Head: CASE SCENARIO Assess a Case Scenario to Foster a Culture of E \LaChara S. Hill Northcentral University Ethics and Criminal Justice – CJ7011-8 Gabriele Suboch December 6, 2015 Introduction The law enforcement officers, in particular the police, are governed by a set of rules that control their activity while on duty; such is to safeguard the rights of the public as well as their safety, and that of the police officer on duty. Law enforcement exists a job that requires men and women of integrity. In view of the fact that, the values and morals associated with......

Words: 3572 - Pages: 15

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Running head: ETHICS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE 1 Facing Ethics in Criminal Justice Through a Christian Worldview Jordan Kopko A Senior Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation in the Honors Program Liberty University Spring 2011 ETHICS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE 2 Acceptance of Senior Honors Thesis This Senior Honors Thesis is accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation from the Honors Program of Liberty University. ______________________________ Stephen Parke, J.D., L.L.M. Thesis Chair ______________________________ Charles Murphy, Ph.D. Committee Member ______________________________ Shelah Simpson, M.A. Committee Member ______________________________ Brenda Ayres, Ph.D. Honors Director ______________________________ Date ETHICS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE 3 Abstract The purpose of this thesis is to express the need for young men and women in law enforcement to endure ethical dilemmas through a Christian worldview. Ethical dilemmas and moral struggles in the criminal justice field are described in detail throughout the thesis. In the decision-making process during an ethical dilemma, an officer with a Christian worldview should make better decisions with the added guidance from the Holy Spirit. This thesis delves into the different aspects of ethics including reasons why some police officers make immoral decisions. The ethical issues in criminal justice have been a problem in law......

Words: 8552 - Pages: 35

Criminal Justice Ethics

...Why is the philosophy of community policing different than other police approaches? (2) How and why is it difficult to implement the philosophy of community policing? Remember, you must use at least one quote from the text in this assignment. Respond to at least three of your classmates. There are many different approaches when it comes to policing such as the watchman, legalistic, and service styles. There is also traditional, problem-oriented, zero-tolerance and community policing, which I will be addressing. Many people think of police as guardians of the community and although this may be true, not all police have the task of looking after the actual community. The array of job descriptions varies but all serve a purpose in the justice system. I will go over why the philosophy of community policing is different than other police approaches, why it is difficult to implement, the philosophy of community policing, and how it is similar to different types or styles of policing. According to Fuller (2014) “While the police have traditionally defined their primary mission in terms of crime control, community policing seeks to broaden the police role to include such issues as fear of crime, order maintenance, conflict resolution, neighborhood decay, and social and physical disorder as basic responsibilities”(p. 234). The philosophy of community policing is different than other police approaches because in this style of policing the officers are in touch with the......

Words: 937 - Pages: 4

Criminal Justice Ethics Paper

...I work in the criminal justice system and every decision requested needs balancing concern. Our concern is prosecuting the guilty and respecting the right of the accused protecting the victims and creating a safe community. I work with my partner where we handle the majority of homicide cases in our town. A woman who was walking alone in the city was brutally raped, beaten and left for dead. After the attack the women was in coma. In that part of the city a young gang had been terrorizing people committing different types of crimes. Early that evening, a young man was seen in the area assaulting and threatening others, who were passing by where the attack took place. The respondent officials picked up two young men 14 years old near the location of the crime after they fled the scene and they were held for questioning by the police. My partner and I have been assigned to this case. We already apprehended the two male 14 year olds. They have previous criminal records for robbery and assault and are members of a gang. The law states that minors must be informed of their legal rights to have their parents present during the interview and the proper use of videotape during the interviews. In spite of this, my partner decides to push aside his ethical obligation and precede the interview alone with them without following the correct procedure. Our responsibility as law enforcement is to follow the guiding principle and moral standards of our police department and do what is......

Words: 347 - Pages: 2

Ethics and Leadership in Criminal Justice

...Ethics and Leadership in Criminal Justice 1 Final Exam 1. Universal responsibility. I’d like to start out by defining the two.1. Universal-means of or pertaining to the universe, all nature, or all existing things. 2.Responsibility-to make one's actions and task their own, the willing acceptance of the consequences of my actions. Individuals, Institutions, Governments and International organizations make judgment about what is just and what is unjust based on a complex and general frameworks of moral and political values. These frameworks vary considerably across cultures and over time, but through the centuries prophets, philosophers and other intellectuals have repeatedly attempted to identify common ground that would allow all human beings in their own and in successive generations to agree on definitions of right and wrong, good and bad, just and unjust. By far the greatest single danger facing humankind – in fact, all living beings on our planet-is the threat of nuclear destruction. I would like to appeal to the leaders of the nuclear powers who literally hold the future of the world and their hands, to the scientists and technicians who continue to create these awesome weapons of destruction, and to all the people at large who are in a position to influence their leaders I appeal to them to exercise their sanity and began to work at dismantling and destroying all nuclear weapons, because we all know that......

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Sarah Polley | Family Blood | Tarzan.und.Jane.S01.German.DL.720p.WEB.x264-BiGiNT