Detroit Bailout

In: Historical Events

Submitted By patte485
Words 2297
Pages 10
Mackenzie Patterson
2008 U.S. Automaker Crisis: The Detroit Bailout
At the end of 2008, two of the three largest domestic automakers in the U.S. received significant financial assistance from the federal government and President Bush’s administration. General Motors and Chrysler were burning through their cash reserves and heading quickly towards insolvency and potential bankruptcy, endangering not only themselves and their workers, but also the large domestic auto parts supplier industry as well. Insolvency had the potential to permanently alter and possibly destroy a large segment of the U.S. industrial economy. In an effort to avoid this, the federal government stepped in with highly controversial assistance in what is now generally referred to as the Detroit Bailout. The question then, as continues to be debated to today, is should the federal government have stepped in and provided help, or should they have left the free trade market alone? There are many opinions and multiple ideologies in the U.S., but which ideas are going to work? These were very difficult decisions that needed to be thoroughly analyzed and debated, however, the urgency of the situation, along with a general collapse in world financial markets led to events quickly overtaking prudence. In the United States, the country is roughly divided into too ideologies, free-market liberalism (conservatives), and social liberalism (liberals). This led to both free-market liberals and social liberals having opinions and making decisions that did not necessarily fit neatly within the general platforms of the Democratic and Republican parties.
After dominating the world for much of the 20th century, General Motors, Chrysler and Ford were on a long, downwards decline; their cars were not competitive with foreign manufacturers as they cost too much, the quality was lower, they were too large, and…...

Similar Documents

Bank Bailout

...2008 Bank Bailout Economic crisis that strike a nation don’t happen from night to dawn, several factors attribute for an economic crisis to happen similar to a meltdown. This was the case for the 2008 economic crisis in America since the great depression that collapsed the stock market in 1929. Several are needed for a market to crash and crumble in pieces, risky investments, reckless decision making, and investments taking on a greater risks in hopes of greater returns are believed to be what caused the 2008 economic crisis in America. I believe that the bailout plan helped in the short term but will have its negative effects in the long run. The private sector in America especially the banks have a huge impact on the economy; there’s a lot of competition in that aspect of the economy. I believe that when the government intervenes in a free market economy and in the private sector it has to be with rules, regulations and under certain circumstances. The banks cannot just take risks loan money without checking first if the person can pay. For every act there is a consequence that has to be faced. The banks can’t just expect for the government to save them every time the feel they will go bankrupt. The government has stepped in several times since the beginning of 2008 to assist failing financial institutions. In September 2008, the federal government extended $85 billion to the American International Group, the country’s largest insurer and one of the world’s largest......

Words: 319 - Pages: 2

The Role of the U.S. Congress in the Auto Bailout

...THE ROLE OF THE U.S. CONGRESS IN THE AUTO BAILOUT The Role of the U.S. Congress in the Auto Bailout Chandria Metevia April 8, 2012 Dr. A. Christophe General Motors General Motors Corporation (GM) is the world's largest full-line vehicle manufacturer and marketer. Its brands include Chevrolet, GMC, Buick, Cadillac, Saturn, Hummer, Saab and Pontiac, which was discontinued in 2009. Opel, Vauxhall, and Holden comprise GM's international nameplates. GM system of global alliances, GM holds stakes in Isuzu Motors Ltd., Fuji Heavy Industries Ltd., Suzuki Motor Corporation, Fiat Auto, and GM Daewoo Auto & Technology. Other principal businesses include General Motors Acceptance Corporation and its subsidiaries, providers of financing and insurance to GM customers and dealers. The company has approximately 326,000 employees. ( General Motors is one of the world's largest auto manufactures. . It was the world’s largest car maker from 1931 to 2008, when it was surpassed by Toyota ( The company was founded in 1908, and today manufactures cars and truck domestically and internationally. For most of the 20th century, General Motors was the biggest company in the industry worldwide. It not only led in automotive innovations, but it helped to define the new bureaucratic multinational corporations that shaped the post-war economy. Chrysler Chrysler LLC, for years America's third-biggest automaker, is a U.S....

Words: 1234 - Pages: 5

After Bailout

...AFTER THE BAILOUT: REGULATING SYSTEMIC MORAL HAZARD* Karl S. Okamoto ** How do we prevent excessive risk taking in the financial markets? This Essay offers a strategy for regulating financial markets to better prevent the kind of disaster we saw during the Financial Crisis of 2008. By developing a model of risk-manager decisionmaking, this Essay illustrates how even “good people” acting in utterly rational and expected ways brought us into economic turmoil. The assertion of this Essay is that the root cause of the Financial Crisis was systemic moral hazard. Systemic moral hazard poses a unique challenge in crafting a regulatory response. The challenge lies in that the best response to systemic moral hazard is “predictive prevention.” It is inherently difficult to reward individuals for producing predictive prevention. Unsurprisingly, markets fail to produce it at optimal levels and thus cannot prevent systemic moral hazard and the kind of crises that ensue. The difficulty in valuing predictive prevention is seen when we model how risk managers make decisions regarding the prevention of excessive risk. The model reveals how the balance can be tipped in favor of risk taking that leads to systemic failure and broad social harm. The model also reveals how regulation might work to reset the balance to one that is superior for society. We can achieve optimal risktaking decisionmaking in two ways: (1) by requiring all asset managers in the market to put their own money at risk......

Words: 26469 - Pages: 106

Understanding the Bailout

...THE BAILOUT Understanding the bailout The turmoil in the mortgage and financial markets, but also fears of recession, have pushed the government to act in order to prevent further worsening of the crisis. As the situation was getting worse month by month, government bailing out one financial firm after another (Bear Stearns in March, AIG in September), and letting fail some (Lehman Bros), a more global approach to address the problem was needed. The bailout proposal, initiated by the Secretary of the Treasury, Henry Paulson, a former executive of Goldman Sachs, was intended to create an entity whereas the government was going to buy those mortgage backed securities from the banks in order to provide liquidity to the banks and clear their balance sheets of these unmarketable assets. Although nobody understands exactly what the plan is and how it will help the economy, since it has changed since the legislation was passed by the U.S. Congress (angering investors in the meantime), there is a consensus that the government will have to step in to clear up the mess on “wall street” and on “Main Street”. In order to understand why there is a need for a bailout, I will retrace the roots of the crisis up to the point where the government decided to intervene. Also, I will address the issue of how the measures undertaken will impact on the banks, the credit markets, mortgage markets and the overall economy. Finally, I will provide an opinion as to why I think the bailout......

Words: 2135 - Pages: 9

Opportunity for Detroit

...July 18, 2013, Detroit filed for a historic Chapter 9 bankruptcy, the largest city in America to ever do so. Once a very prosperous city, Detroit has seen a material decline in its’ population, from about 1.8 million in 1950 to about 700,000 residents today, nearly 20% of whom are unemployed. This huge decline can be attributed to not only a decline in manufacturing jobs and the automobile industry, but also Detroit’s public safety woes. Coupled with a decreasing tax base and an increasing debt burden, Detroit’s decision and policy makers ultimately drove themselves into insolvency. However, the City of Detroit is taking several measures to try and claw out of the mess they are in in hopes of returning them to the wealthiest US city per capita (again). Now that Detroit is at its breaking point, the city's emergency manager Kevyn Orr has requested that the Detroits Institute of Arts collection will be appraised by New York auction house Christie’s. An estimate suggests that the collection would be worth well over $1 billion dollars and the appraisal is a crucial step in rebuilding the city and establishing a trust with creditors. Despite numerous denials from Orr and the museum leadership that the art collection will be sold, this has caused an outrage in the art community. Orr has commented that selling the cities assets is a last ditch effort. Detroit and its surrounding communities are actively seeking other means to bring the city back to life. Detroit has been......

Words: 1044 - Pages: 5

Detroit Bancruptcy

...The City of Detroit bankruptcy is a historical event since the city of Detroit is one of the largest cities ever filed for bankruptcy. However, the court trial will decide after considering all the facts and testimonials, if City of Detroit will qualify for bankruptcy. City of Detroit has filed for bankruptcy mainly because of financial factors such as expenditures were higher than revenues, the high level of debts and bad management. In the audit report issued for the 2012 there were many qualified and adverse opinions with regards to the financial statements. The fact that City of Detroit filed for bankruptcy, as hard as it might be, would give the city a new start and a new way of managing and thinking. This city needs restructuring and functioning under a new economic vitality. By developing new strategic plans such as new employment opportunities and offering reliable services for its residents and businesses, city of Detroit will regain its role in the economic vitality of Michigan. The economy of Detroit plays a key role in the economic development of Michigan. City of Detroit is known as the Motor City for the innovations in the auto industry but also for its goal diversifications into emerging fields such as information technology and advanced manufacturing. Encouraging advantage are the different tax incentive programs that city of Detroit offers. For example, Detroit Renaissance Zone Tax includes a waiver of city income and utility users taxes, most city......

Words: 315 - Pages: 2

The Government Bailout

...The government has requested and approved taking 700 billion dollars of tax payers money, with what is now being called (EESA) Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008, but it is better known as the “Bailout” (One Hundred and Tenth Congress of the United States of America. Pages 1-169). For an expensive and critical Act, not much is known or published about it. While this Act is the most expensive in US history, did you know that the US has a long history of bailouts? Do you know what this Act is about? Do you know who will be paying for the Act? Who is at fault for this crisis? The Emergency Economic Stabilization Act is not a new concept to the US Government. From the 1970’s to the present date there have been thirteen of them. There have been five of bailouts in 2008 alone, with two of those being mortgage related. One for 200 billion dollars to government sponsored enterprises Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. (Alford paragraph 1) The second mortgage related bailout is for 30 billion to Bear Stearns. This bailout is the largest proposed and approved bailout in US history. (Nankin, Umansky, Kjellman, Klein). The United States is not the only country feeling the effect of financial fallout. Countries such as France, Germany, Portugal, and Spain face similar bailouts topping out at two trillion dollars. (Chu, Retzlaff P 1) To help market stability and the US economy, the Bush administration proposed the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act in September 2008. The......

Words: 1319 - Pages: 6

Aig Bailout

...Can We Expect A Regulated CDS Market? Derivatives Project Xilin Yang (Celine) Introduction The article introduces credit default swaps and explores the problems of the credit derivatives. By analyzing the AIG’s bailout, the article describes the regulation gap in the CDS market and states the regulation reform after the crisis. Part I is background, generally introduces the Wall Street crisis. How it happened? What consequence it has? Part II is mainly about AIG’s CDS business: how AIG got involved in the crisis and why the biggest world insurance company suddenly collapsed. Part III is about credit default swaps: definition, construction, and problems. Part IV is concerned on the regulation reform after AIG’s failure. Wall Street Crisis Speaking of the Wall Street crisis, people all know it proceed from subprime crisis. The relatively low interest rate prompts banks to issue large amount of housing loans. To transfer default risk embedded in those loans, investment banks package those loans and mortgages into student loans, car loans and credit card debt, which form the so-called collateralized debt obligation (CDOs). All these derivatives depend on the housing loans. In the era of low interest rates, house prices rise rapidly and promote the rapid development of the housing loans business. With steady stream of housing loans into financial derivatives products, different ranks of products are packaged to sale out. The good view of economy makes those potentially......

Words: 2738 - Pages: 11

The Automotive Bailout

...Running head: AUTOMOTIVE BAILOUT The Automotive Industry Bailout: Rewriting History ECON 625: Managerial Economics Abstract The automobile has long been a symbol of American growth and prosperity. Throughout the 20th Century owning and driving a car was an essential part of everyday life for vast majority of U.S. citizens, but few took much time to think about how they were manufactured. Early in the 21st Century, as the U.S. economy began to trend downward, it became apparent that two of the three primary automakers were in significant financial peril. With government aid already being allocated to some of the nation’s largest financial institutions, difficult decisions had to made as to how to approach the alarming crisis at the heart of an industry woven throughout the lives of so many United States citizens. Introduction Beginning in the early twentieth century, automobile makers began marketing and ultimately selling cars to middle-class Americans. It did not take long for a deep love affair for cars to develop across the nation, and ownership became woven into the fabric of the “American Dream”. The invention of the assembly line in the 1910s made automobiles relatively inexpensive, and by 1929 it is estimated that American car companies were producing 5.3 million cars per year (Miller-Wilson, n.d.). The automotive industry surely had its share of ups and downs during the 1900’s, with two World Wars, the Great Depression, an oil crisis in the 1970’s,...

Words: 3848 - Pages: 16


...After starting as a small trading post in the eighteenth century, Detroit went on to become an industrial power house. However, as beautiful as it may seem, the modern Detroit is not the same city it was prior to 1960. In the last half-century, the city has been struck by crime and violence. That is when an "All-American City" became an eyesore, a blighted spot on the map. Attempts to reverse this downward trend have been made throughout the years; major construction projects appeared, and continue to appear, everywhere in Detroit. One of the most significant projects was the remodeling of Campus Martius. It was completed over a decade ago. This plaza still remains as the main gathering place for Detroiters and a great advertisement for the City of Detroit. With all the completed and yet to be completed projects, it may seem that Detroit is far past its decay; however, when one takes a closer look at any of the Detroit landmarks, one will see that Detroit appears to be beautiful only on the outside. The city and its elected officials have created a fake impression of perfection. Unfortunately, just one block away from these "pockets of improvement" is the true Detroit. Campus Martius was established in the eighteenth century as a military training ground. It is important to note that prior to 1805 Detroit was designed in a grid system. In 1805, a fire engulfed Detroit and destroyed Campus Martius and all wooden structures, leaving only a stone fort untouched (Beckett).......

Words: 1828 - Pages: 8

My Happy Detroit

...Changing the Narrative * An Analysis and discussion of “My Happy Detroit” Ruined streets, echoing car alarms and dilapidated buildings all combine to provide the perfect scenery for a post-apocalyptic film. However, there is nothing dramatized about this image - It is the concerning reality of modern day Detroit. At least, that has been the narrative in the media since the latter part of the sixties. Carolyn Edgar, who spent her childhood in Detroit, tells another story. Carolyn Edgar graduated with a bachelor degree in English with high distinction, giving her opinion academic reliability. Her work consists mostly of writing for internet blogs. She has worked consistently for the progressive, liberal magazine Salon for the last three years. She was raised in Detroit, and she mostly has fond memories of the city. This is why she wants to dismantle the message in the media. Edgar appeals to pathos by telling anecdotes of her childhood, in order to rebut the common narrative of the media. She begins by painting an idyllic scene: Children playing at a barbecue. “While the ribs were on the grill, we would play Motown hits on the record player another cousin brought over for the occasion”(ll. 7-8). This image immediately creates empathy and identification with the reader, and dismantles the image that the common person has of Detroit as a dilapidated city. By anchoring the reader with an emotional standpoint right from the beginning, Carolyn establishes a bond of......

Words: 1034 - Pages: 5


...Detroit – Essay In the beginning many went to Detroit to pursuit the American Dream. Then in the early 1900’s Henry Ford an American industrialist, and the founder of the Ford Motor Company, and also the sponsor of the development of the assemble line to do mass production. He brought mass production of the automobile to Detroit, making it a place where you could secure your economics, and many could get a job with pension afterwards. The base of Detroit’s economics laid its ground in the automobile industry for quite some time. The automobile industry through the 20th century had many good years but also a lot of bad years. Many factories’ met a wall, which lead to a lot of lay-offs and which furthermore not only hurt the Detroit’s economics but the United States as well. A lot of times when you think about Detroit you get this picture of a ghetto city, with a great deal of violence and “black people”. This might be the reason for Carolyn Edgar to write the article “My happy Detroit”. In the start of the article Carolyn writes “The city didn’t die when the white flight hit in the 1960s. It became a bastion for black families like mine.” This is might her way of telling that there is still people living there, and we should not just forget them even though the city has been on a downfall. Growing up Carolyn Edgar loved the summer, their garden was in full bloom, and they had the opportunity of enjoying strawberries, cucumber and so on. As she Carolyn says herself “You......

Words: 828 - Pages: 4


...Bailout Money Awarded to Major Bank Executives Their Impacts on Utilitarianism and Deontology Price TUI University Abstract This paper explores two published articles that report on banks receiving billions of taxpayers’ dollars awarded from the government known as the Trouble Asset Relief Program (TARP), who in turn paid their top executives billions of dollars for bonuses. TARP is a program to assist in the stability and strengthen its financial sector by paying for bad mortgages and other trouble assets. In order to prevent economic collapse, the Bush administration changed the programs goals. (Gold, 2008) Using the TARP funds to support and pay off executive’s bonuses poses a moral dilemma within society, which I will later discuss in the paper. The purpose of this paper is to answer the question, Should top executives of the major banks that received bail-out money be allowed to receive large bonuses? I will present my personal view on the matter using the bases of my values, beliefs and research that I have done on the topic. In addition, I will explain how bailout money awarded to major bank use for executives bonuses impacts on utilitarianism and deontology. Bailout Money Awarded to Major Bank Executives and their Impacts on Utilitarianism and Deontology The United States began experiencing the recession during the early years of 2000. On September, 11, 2001 a tragedy in New York City occurred when the World Trade Center Towers were struck......

Words: 1918 - Pages: 8

Gmc Bailout

...investors owning 1,000 shares and empire is born. At 9:30 in the morning on this day, June 16, 1903, Henry Ford and other prospective stockholders in the Ford Motor Company meet in Detroit to sign the official paperwork required to create a new corporation. Twelve stockholders were listed on the forms, which were signed, notarized and sent to the office of Michigan’s secretary of state. Henry Ford (255 shares), Alexander Y. Malcomson (255 shares), John S. Gray (105 shares), John W. Anderson (50 shares), Horace Rackham (50 shares), Horace E. Dodge (50 shares), John F. Dodge (50 shares), Chrles T. Bennett (50 shares), Vernon C. Fry (50 shares), Albert Strelow (50 shares), James Couzens (25 shares), Charles J. Woodall (10 shares).  The company was officially incorporated the following day, when the secretary of state’s office received the articles of association. Ford had built his first gasoline-powered vehicle–which he called the Quadricycle–in a workshop behind his home in 1896, while he was working as the chief engineer for the main plant of the Edison Illuminating Company in Detroit. He made two unsuccessful attempts to start a company to manufacture automobiles before 1903. A month after the Ford Motor Company was established, the first Ford car was assembled at a plant on Mack Avenue in Detroit. In the early days of Ford, only a few cars were assembled per day, and they were built by hand by small groups of workers from parts made to order by other companies. With......

Words: 1285 - Pages: 6

Government Bailouts

...Government Bailouts    Economist believe that allowing financial institutions and international corporations to go bankrupt could have a far reaching effect on the government and in particular on the citizens who depend on these organizations Companies such as AIG, Chrysler, Ford, General Motors, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac should receive bailouts because they provide essential products and services for their consumers as well as provide numerous job opportunities to the citizens of the state. According to the supporters of the bailout plan, the economy needs rescue and helping out banks and other institutions in financial crisis will go far in reviving the economy as well. Take for example the case of AIG which received $85 billion bailout loan from the government in 2008. Why would the government not let the company close up? AIG can be described as 'too big to fail'. This logic is that if financial firms or corporations go under it can drag others with them (Fernholz, 2009). AIG the insurance giant provides insurance cover for major companies and individuals in the U.S and other countries. If the company went bankrupt then a lot of losses could be felt in the economy as millions of covers and policies go unpaid. While we may not be able to fully blame bankers and other corporate heads for the economic meltdown that followed a market-wide failure in 2008, but it does seem that bankers want to take advantage of profits when the economy is good and then pass......

Words: 863 - Pages: 4

YouRe Under Arrest! Mini Specials | Face Your Fears | Nailed It - Season 2