Female Circumcision

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By 2clint2
Words 1949
Pages 8
Female Circumcision

Human Rights? We all have them, don’t we? That is the question I had to ask myself repeatedly while reading about this controversial issue. How far can or should you take the issue when dealing with cultural traditions? Over the past 3 weeks, I have done a lot of research on this topic and have found many things that I did not know. At first, when I read the two articles, honestly, I was more grossed out than anything. I did not really care; I just thought how weird it was going to be to try to write a paper on this topic. The main thing that ran through my mind was, “Why do people even care, men get circumcised every day.” However, after doing research and learning more, I decided it was so much more than that. Marrilee H. Salmon, a professor of science, states in her article how unmoral and degrading the process of female circumcision is. I strongly agree with her opinion and the opinion of many other feminist anthropologists, who are desperately trying to help eliminate this procedure. Salmon also goes on to tell how female circumcision is an act of power more than anything, giving men power and/or authority over women. And it truly is, I mean how is this beneficial to women at all? Every one is entitled to their own opinion and mine is expressed exactly in Marrilee’s article when she says, “it’s also called genital mutilation!” That is exactly what this is, “MUTILATION,” and I definitely agree with putting a stop to it. I also feel that anthropologists have a responsibility in this matter. They should try to educate these villagers and societies in an effort to eliminate this act of indecency. Since anthropologists may have more frequent contact with these people, they should make them aware of the dangers, and available options, despite previous culture practices or traditions. This inhumane practice needs to be…...

Similar Documents


...Topic: Is Infant Circumcision Really Necessary? Circumcision, (in Latin circumcidere, means "to cut around"), “is the surgical removal of the foreskin of the penis” ("Circumcision," 2013). This is a practice that may be performed to an infant baby boy after birth or to a boy who is just approaching adolescence depending on the cultures or beliefs of the parents. There are many arguments concerning the best time for boys to undergo this procedure, and whether or not they should undergo this procedure. And like many surgical procedures, there are risks and benefits that may result from going through with this surgery. I believe in doing what is important and what is best for the child, meaning; catering to the boy’s interest is what I advocate. “There is compelling evidence that male circumcision reduces the risk of heterosexually acquired HIV infection in men by approximately 60%” ("Male circumcision for," 2012). World Health Organization also describes the efficacy of circumcision as proven beyond reasonable doubt, but states that provision of circumcision should be consistent with medical ethics and human rights principles. ("Male circumcision for," 2012). WHO and UNAIDS stated that “Informed consent, confidentiality and absence of coercion should be assured. . . . Where male circumcision is provided for minors (young boys and adolescents), there should be involvement of the child in the decision-making, and the child should be given the opportunity to provide assent or......

Words: 1382 - Pages: 6


...Circumcision Brianna Restrepo COMM/215 ESSENTIALS OF COLLEGE WRITING July 1, 2013 Professor Karen Lawler Circumcision To cut or not to cut? Will this procedure harm my child? What does my child gain from this procedure? These are questions all parents of little boys may be faced with when it comes to the topic of circumcision. There have been many arguments on whether circumcision is a beneficial procedure or just a cosmetic one. Most of the world does not view circumcision beneficial as the child grows, yet rather views it as a harmful procedure that the child cannot consent to depending on his age. It has been said that “there have been efforts in a number of countries to forbid the circumcision of infants and children.” (Isaacs, 2011) Despite the current decrease in circumcisions the most common reasons for this procedure to be done on a child are due to religious traditions, that the child’s father is circumcised, and the health benefits. As a firm believer that there are health benefits to this procedure, this paper will go over some of the benefits of circumcising your male child as well as the risks involved in the procedure. One of the health benefits that a child obtains from being circumcised is the “protection against a horde of sexually transmitted infections.” (New Internationalist) Some of the sexual transmitted infections or diseases that are reduced in circumcised males are human papillomavirus or also known as HPV, genital herpes, and even human......

Words: 749 - Pages: 3


...Ontario boy dies after complications from circumcision A one-week-old Ontario infant died from complications after undergoing a circumcision in a provincial hospital. The baby, whose name has been withheld by the parents, passed away after his kidneys became enlarged to seven times their normal size. The child was born at an unidentified Ontario hospital and the doctors said that he was born sometime in the last three years and the family wants to keep it anonymous. According to the Pediatric Child Health article, the boy was “bottle-fed” and was reported to be doing well when he was circumcised. Five hours later, the parents returned to their family doctor with the infant, who had become “irritable and had blue discoloration” below the belly button. Doctors noticed the discoloration and slight swelling of the penis, but sent the child home. Fourteen hours after the circumcision, according to the parents, the child was brought to another hospital where doctors noted he was extremely irritable with marked swelling of the penis and bruising to the scrotum. The child was then transferred to a pediatric centre, where his bladder was diagnosed, doctors said that it was even or eight times its normal size. “If the Plastic Bell had been taken off five hours after he got there, he would be alive,” said Doctors. The child’s death was attributed to septic shock — “an overwhelming infection, leading to multi-organ failure.” The case was brought to Cairns’ attention because the......

Words: 1087 - Pages: 5


...* Cross culturally, where, when and how is circumcision performed on males and females. Include information on its legality and actual practice, and the medical implications of this for women and men.  * How should the United States respond when female circumcision is practiced in our country? * How should the United States respond to female circumcision that is practiced in other countries?( review information on values such as "cultural relativisim page 7 of your text, do you think it does or does not apply) * What are your views on other practices regarding changing the appearance of the genitalia, such as the Brazilian wax or labiaplasty? Should we leave the genitalia alone or is there something to be said for "enhancing" the appearance? Any research on this? *   What are the medical, physical, or mental consequences for any of the procedures Male circumcision and female circumcision have some similarities. For the males, they are born with a fold of skin located over the head of the penis. This is called the glans or foreskin. In the circumcision this is surgically removed and is usually performed 48 hours after birth but can be done 2-3 weeks after birth as well. This procedure does not necessarily have any medical benefits. It can possibly prevent penile cancer and infections and possibly reduce the spread of infectious diseases. Circumcision for males is usually done as an American tradition and is thought to be easier to keep clean. The survey...

Words: 478 - Pages: 2

Female Circumcision Persussive Essay

...Female circumcision is a harsh procedure practiced mostly in Africa and the Middle East. It is when a female’s genital organs, such as the labia and clitoris are removed. This ritual continues to be practiced because of the religious and traditional reasons, however there are more reasons behind it. The practice is unfair and wrong and it needs to be stopped. In Waris Dirie’s “The tragedy of female circumcision”, she discusses why female circumcision is practiced. She also shares her personal experience with circumcision, how it affected her, and how she survived and overcame the mental and physical devastation this terrible procedure left behind. Dirie is now doing everything in her power to prevent this from happening to anymore girls. The practice of female circumcisions is not performed in a sanitary environment nor are they done by professionals. Dirie states “The woman who did it called herself a “professional cutter but she was just an old gypsy who traveled around with her bag” [Dirie, 177]. The woman who did her circumcision wasn’t a qualified professional of any kind to perform such a procedure. Also this woman didn’t use sterile tools to perform this operation. Dirie stated “The old woman held a dirty razor with someone else’s blood residue on it [Dirie, 177]. This is unsanitary and raises health issues. Dirie could have been exposed to someone else’s germs and blood when she was circumcised. This is a very unsafe practice. It can result in infection and......

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Female Circumsion

...‘heinous’ and ‘unjust’. The most shared problem is that which such practice creates a situation where lives of people are put at risk. An eminent practice which is taken into attention is female genital mutilation. This writing shall discuss clashes between human rights and cultural relativism with my personal stance about these two ethical dilemmas. Female genital mutilation is considered as unlawful act by many people while in several cultures it is a common cultural practice. “Female circumcision is mainly carried out in western and southern Asia, the Middle East and large areas of Africa” (bacquet, 2009). In several cultures, some elderly women carry out these practices without any medical backing. It is a shared practice in many cultures with a belief that it makes a girl clean, beautiful and to kill the erotic longings before they get married. Moving on, female genital mutilation is said to rear conflicts amid human rights and cultural relativism. Female circumcision violates human rights because each human being is born to live and make their personal decisions. However at it is also a religious act so one cannot just overlook their religious norms and values. According to African Women’s Organization female genital mutilation has many immoral effects. It causes injuries to the female genital organs which results in bleeding, urinary problem, and infertility (Organisation, 2011). According to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the following articles of......

Words: 1195 - Pages: 5

Female Genitalia

...Rites of Passage: Female Genitalia Cutting Cultural Anthropology ANT101 Rites of Passage: Female Genitalia Cutting Have you heard of Female Genitalia Cutting or FGC? It is not an unknown practice here in the United States, but laws prevent it from occurring here. In other cultures in other countries Female Genitalia Cutting is being performed to children as young as 5 years old. In Cultures like Maasai in Tanzania and Shendi in Sudan these procedures are being performed on children as young as three. Is this a form of mutilation? Or is it the right thing to do to a child? Growing up in these cultures they are taught that this is the right thing that must be done, to show that they are fertile, to show their fidelity. A tradition that goes back over a hundred years and their “stubbornness” to end tradition keeps this rite of passage going. Female Genitalia Cutting is the cutting of the female external genitalia, there are four forms of female genitalia cutting according to the World Health Organization also known as WHO. Clitoridectomy, excision, infibulation and other which is any harmful procedure done for non-medical reasons such as piercings. All of these procedures are normally done by a person who has no medical training and can cause death or infection to the person it is being practiced on. Clitoridectomy is cutting the clitoris as what the name says, the excision removes the clitoris and labia minora and the most invasive is the infibulation......

Words: 1577 - Pages: 7

Female Husbands

...marriage is between a female wife and a male husband. However, within the Nandi society, the existence of woman/woman marriage is apparent. The aim of this essay is to discuss and evaluate whether the female husband in this woman/woman union is a man, with reference to the article, “Is the Female Husband a Man. Woman/Woman Marriage among the Nandi of Kenya, written by Oboler. The factors that will be discussed will be the requirements for inheritance, gender roles and the husband/wife and husband/child relationship. One can suggest that the female husband is not a man due to the pure fact that biologically the female husband is not a male but a female. The first factor that will be discussed is the requirements for inheritance. Within the Nandi society property and livestock is held and managed exclusively by men. (Oboler, R.S.1980:136) Therefore, a son is needed to transfer ownership of land and livestock from one generation to the next. In instances where a woman has born no sons, she marries a younger women in the hope that she may bear a male child in order to provide an heir for her assets. Sons are also needed to continue the family name else the family name will die. In conventional families and households the role of man is breadwinner, protector and provider. Men are responsible for certain aspects of physical labour, they oversee livestock e.g. cattle and hold the position of head on the household. Within the woman/woman marriage the female husband, “adopts the......

Words: 1011 - Pages: 5

Female Mutation

...Sean Joseph, RN Female Genital Mutilation Controversy The removal of external female genitalia has been part of a celebrated ritual in the lives of girls and women in some cultures and countries for centuries. Despite growing international campaign to abolish female genital mutilation (FGM), many still see this tradition as an effective and acceptable method of controlling women's attitudes toward sex and sexuality and of ensuring their virginity and suitability for marriage. An estimated 120 million girls and women have undergone FGM, and approximately 2 million procedures are performed annually on girls under the age of 11, most commonly performed in Africa, it is also practiced in parts of Southeast Asia, the Middle East and in Central and South America. In countries such as Sierra Leone, an estimated 90% of women have undergone FGM. A least invasive form of FGM known as the clitoridectomy, also known by the Arabic term Sunna, involves excision of the prepuce and part or the entire clitoris. The second form, "excision," involves removal of the clitoris and part or all of the labia minor. "Infibulation," which means "to fasten with a clip or buckle," is the most invasive form and is most common in Somalia, Ethiopia, parts of Kenya and the Sudan. It involves removal of the clitoris, all of the labia minor and part or all of the labia majora, and the pinning or stitching of the two sides of the vulva closed. A narrow opening is left for urinary and menstrual outflow......

Words: 608 - Pages: 3

Female Mutilation

...Female Genital Mutilation Female genital mutilation is done to women in countries such as: Africa, the Middle East, and South East Asia. It is a procedure in which the genitals of a young girl or child or removed or circumcised. In countries where this is practiced, society practices it as a tradition and those who do not are not accepted. There are several side effects from going forth with the practice of female genital mutilation. This includes: urine complications, bleeding, scaring, pregnancy complications, aids, mental issues, and even resulting in death. Even with all of the negative effects of Female Genital Mutilation, if given the option of pro-choice, some girls would not feel untraditional, it will not be practiced illegally, and there could be better medical procedures taken into consideration. History of Female Genital Mutilation In America, it is natural for a parent to choose to have their son circumcised. Before, it was not permissible. Unfortunately, in areas like Africa, Middle East, and Southeast Asia, it is unacceptable for a mother or grandmother to have their daughter circumcised, also known as female genital mutilation. The clitoris or other genital parts are cut out with a small blade or a piece of glass, and then it is sewn together. Due to the fact that it is considered inhumane or an act of force. People feel as if the rights of these little girls are being violated, thus for making it illegal in the......

Words: 688 - Pages: 3

Secrecy Surrounding the Practice of Female Circumcision in Mabvuku and Tafara Surburbs

...CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION Female circumcision is a traditional practice performed on girl children as part of initiation rituals into adulthood. This inquiry seeks to demystify the secretiveness surrounding this practice, seeking to establish the reasons why female circumcision remains a taboo subject. In doing so, the researcher will attempt to establish the local community’s perception of female circumcision and elucidate some of the reasons practitioners cite as benefits of female circumcision. The research focuses on Mabvuku and Tafara suburbs because there are people of different ethnic groups with varying customs and values that shape their behaviour and way of life. Mabvuku and Tafara have an unusually high concentration of people of Malawian, Mozambican and Zambian origin who migrated to seek work mostly before the Zimbabwean independence. Due to this diversity, women and girls who have undergone female circumcision were interviewed. Mabvuku is a high-density suburb some seventeen kilometres east of Harare. It is classified as a suburb or township of Harare, with the Harare City Council constituting local government. This inquiry is exploratory, descriptive and qualitative in nature, based on interviews with women who had undergone the practice in Mabvuku-Tafara. The inquiry can be termed therefore, a qualitative research done through a case study design. This research method is preferred because the researcher is exploring a subjective understanding of social......

Words: 24160 - Pages: 97

Immorality of Female Circumcision

...Circumcision is a touchy and controversial topic that has been sweeping our world and the religious and ethical views that come with it. Female circumcision is the practice of removing a female’s external genitalia—most notably, the clitoris and labia. This practice is common in Africa and the Middle East; in contrast, it is frowned upon in the Western hemisphere and even illegal in the UK. Female circumcision is performed on young, helpless girls who have no say in whether they want the procedure performed or not—their parents and community decide for them. In addition, the procedure is performed by a non-certified practitioner who “uses a small knife or razor blade but no anesthesia” (Ashford). Female mutilation is morally wrong and unethical due to the fact that it is an unnecessary procedure that carries many medical risks and serious infections without any medical benefits, and because the girls who are circumcised are not given a choice whether they want to be circumcised or not. There are many stakeholders involved in the practice of female circumcision—not just the girl. In addition to the girl who is being mutilated, other individuals include her family and the “practitioner” who performs the circumcision on her. The Somalian government is also a stakeholder because they choose to condone the practice. Systemic stakeholders include the Westerners (Americans and Europeans), activist groups, other Somalians, and lenders. Lenders also in the wrong, if they......

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

The Significance of Circumcision

...The Significance of Circumcision In an article from the Journal for the Study of the Old Testament in June 2000, Dr. John Goldingay writes about circumcision. Dr. Goldingay is currently the David Allan Hubbard Professor of the Old Testament at Fuller Theological Seminary. He is also an author, writing several novels to include Men Behaving Badly and After Eating the Apricot. Dr. Goldingay also holds a membership on the Society of Biblical Literature and serves on the editorial board for the Library of Hebrew/Old Testament Studies (Fuller). In his article, Dr. Goldingay discusses the troubling issues behind circumcision. Why did the Lord choose to make this one sign of belief exclusive to men? Most signs of the covenant can apply to everyone, but circumcision can only apply to men. There have been many attempts to justify the significance of gender-exclusive submission. One states that when two people become “one flesh” (Gen2.24), only one individual needs the mark of the covenant. This speculation has not been convincing (Goldingay). There have been several reasons to justify the use of this practice. Possibly the reason the Lord chose this act of dedication was to ensure further offspring for his followers. By removing the foreskin it promotes fertility. With fertility, the Israelites can hope to gain economic power, status and greater achievement. Other traditional motivations include cleanliness or hygiene, it helps to avoid infection, and it symbolizes the......

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Female Circumsion

...Female Circumcision Circumcision is a topic that is widely discussed and controversial all across the globe. In Western countries, circumcision of infant young males takes place when they are born. In African nations, female circumcision takes place in adolescent life. Is it right or wrong to deprive anyone of their natural born identity and sexual pleasure? In Business Ethics Concepts and Cases 7th Edition by Manuel G. Velasquez, the author defines morality as the standards that an individual or a group has about what is right and wrong or good and evil. As stated, it is up to the individual or group to decide by themselves as to what is right or wrong. Today, Westerners pressure African nations to put a halt to a tradition they’ve held for many years, but fail to see that Westerners hold their own traditions in circumcision of infant males. Who is right? Who is wrong? In Africa, the practice of female circumcision is practiced by doctors on females as young as 7. It allows for various business opportunities for the people in Africa to make a living. Is it morally wrong for the business to perform such acts? Morally, I am against all circumcision because I feel that harming an individual and depriving anyone of sexual pleasure is wrong. However, I do not wish to push my beliefs on others, and therefore if a business wishes to practice this task, by all means. If these business owners ask a Western organization for a loan, it is up to the lender to make the final say.......

Words: 421 - Pages: 2

Female Genital Cutting

...Fatima Said, of Americas Top Model, defiantly put female genital cutting in the minds of Americans and people around the world. She opened up a topic that many people had no idea about, and now are very interested in knowing more about. This essay will give a brief history of Somalia (Fatima’s home country), and then it will go into female genital cutting in Somalia. Somalia is a country in eastern Africa. The countries of Djibouti, Ethiopia, and Kenya surround it. Somalis are thought to have been decedents from Africans and Arab people. The main languages in Somalia are Arabic, Italian and English. Islam is practiced through out the region. The majorities of Somalis are livestock herders and cultivate the land that they have. (www.cia.gov). Somalia became independent and its own country in 1960, when it got independence from England and Italy. Somalia has not had a stable government between 1991 and 2000. However, during 2000 a parliamentary government was formed but later on expired in 2003. In 2004, a new parliament was organized and a president was elected- Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed. Since 1991, Somalia has been overwhelmed with chaos and anarchy. Somalia had gone through a difficult time in 1992 when a drought happened in Africa and was combined with a civil war. Somalia went through an intense famine that killed approximately 300,000 people. (www.cia.gov). There were many efforts done by the United Stated and the United Nations to help Somalia get through the drought......

Words: 1587 - Pages: 7

Extreme Landings Pro Full Cracked | Criminal Minds | Blackish S04E19 720p HDTV x264-AVS [eztv]