Premium Essay

: Negligence, Product Liability, Warranties, and Really Hot Coffee - Homework Es

In: Business and Management

Submitted By moony12
Words 1622
Pages 7
1.The duty, this element requires plaintiff to act like an ordinary careful person.
2.Breach of Duty, which comes after establishing standard of care; hotel was negligence, the hotel should have protected its gusts, and it should have monitored the elevators from any strangers.
3.Causation, this element comes after the establishment of the breach of duty. This element often used to determine the causes of an accident. The “but for” test which determines the defendant action or absence of action, that could have prevented the injury.
4.Proximate Cause, which is the negligence that cause the injury. It must be the main cause of injury, and not another negligence.
5.Damages, which means that Mr. Margreiter must establish the damages that resulted from the hotel negligence.

1. The duty, this element requires the Mr. Margreiter to act like an ordinary careful person. Also the hotel has a duty to protect the gusts from any attack from a third person. However, the hotel was negligence, because it fails to protect Mr. Margreiter from the attack which happens inside the hotel.

2. Breach of Duty, which comes after establishing standard of care, and determining the duty, the hotel was negligence, the hotel should have protected its gusts, and it should have monitored the elevators from any strangers. Moreover, the hotel does not have cameras, and there were only one guard to monitor the whole hotel which is very huge. The back door has no guard. All of these are a breach of the duty.

3. Causation, this element comes after the establishment of the breach of duty. This element often used to determine the causes of an accident. The “but for” test which determines the defendant action or absence of action, that could have prevented the injury. The criminals have used the elevators of the hotel, and they have attacked Mr. Margreiter at his room inside the hotel.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Chapter 21 Warranties and Liabilities

...Chapter 21 Warranties and Product Liability • Warranty, which is an assurance provided in a sales contract • Negligence, which refers to unreasonable conduct by the defendant • Strict liability, which prohibits defective products whether the defendant acted reasonably or not. A warranty is a contractual assurance that goods will meet certain standards. An express warranty is one that the seller creates with his words or actions. The UCC establishes that the seller may create an express warranty in three ways: (1) with an affirmation of fact or a promise; (2) with a description of the goods; or (3) with a sample or model. In addition, the buyer must demonstrate that what the seller said or did was the basis of the bargain. A statement is more likely to be an affirmation of fact if: • It is specific and can be proven true or false. Suppose the brochures of a home builder promise to meet “the strictest building codes.” Since there is a code on file, the builder's work can be compared to it, and his promise is binding. • It is written. An oral promise can create an express warranty. But promises in brochures are more likely to be taken seriously. Statements in a written contract are the likeliest of all to create a binding warranty. • Defects are not obvious. If a used car salesman tells you that a car is rust free, when the driver's door is pockmarked with rust, you should not take the statement seriously— since a court will not, either. • Seller has greater expertise...

Words: 867 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Product Liability Management

...Product Liability Management Victor Adejayan Dr. Dianne Barrs Strayer University LEG 500 September, 2012 Product liability is the responsibility of a manufacturer for injury or loss caused by its product ( Product liability serves to protect the public but it is may turn out to be very expensive to organizations. Management has the duty of making sure that organizations’ resources, especially funds and reputation, do not suffer unnecessary attrition and damages through the implementation of effective, affordable product liability programs. It is important to have people in management that possess the skills such needed to solve liability issues in the legal arena, most importantly before they occur.The challenge of the manager is fulfilling his/hers responsibilities by generating profit in business while protecting the interests of otherstakeholders, such as, employees and customers. Though the savvy manager cannot stop people from having the intention and grievances to sue the organization, they can reduce the motive of prospective plaintiffs and in event of a lawsuit happens; effective product liability management mitigates the negative effects on the organization. Management has the duty of making sure the product liability policies and programs of the organization is clear, concise and precise so that the interpretation thereof cannot be turned to work against the organization. Most lawsuits that are directed at organizations......

Words: 1890 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Products Liability

...Running Head: Products Liability Assignment 4: Products Liability Name Law and Ethics in the Business Environment Professor February 17, 2013 Products Liability Johnson & Johnson Johnson & Johnson started out making surgical dressing for hospitals and then that progressed into what Johnson & Johnson is best known for is the Band-Aid brand band aid. They added tape to the dressing and the product was convenient for hospitals as well as mending cuts and scrapes that people get, targeting kids because they are accident prone. In later years Johnson & Johnson explored other opportunities mainly in the over-the-counter medicinal products. Over the years they have been subject to many lawsuits but the one this paper will focus on is the product liability lawsuit on the DePuy ASR hip implant. DePuy is a company that specializes in orthopedic products and was acquired by Johnson & Johnson in 1998. The metal on metal hip replacement DePuy ASR was approved by the FDA for use by surgeons on patients that were in need of a hip replacement in 2005. (Meier, 2010). The DePuy ASR hip replacement should have a life of at least 10 years. The device was being used on patients, soon after the DePuy dividion of Johnson & Johnson started receiving complaints of the device with the largest spike of complaints in 2009. (Meier, 2010). Many of the complaints resulted in the patient having to receive another hip replacement only a few......

Words: 1869 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Product Liability and Legal Ramifications

...Product Liability and Legal Ramifications Christopher M. Branch MBA 5861 New Product Marketing 08/13/2013 Christopher Branch MBA 5861 Term 1A Dr. David Castle 08/13/2013 Product Liability and Legal Ramifications The next time you walk into a retail store like Wal-Mart, Target, Home Depot, Office Depot, Babies R’ Us/Toy R’ Us, you will see a board, typically in plain sight of the viewing public, with sheets of papers titled “Product Recall” or Safety Recall or something of the like. Recalled items run the gamut of consumers good and are generally recalled because of a safety or health concerns. The Food and Drug Administration regularly issues recalls or public safety notices for Medical Products, Pharmaceuticals, Tobacco, and contaminated food items. Product Liability is the responsibility of manufacturers, distributors and sellers, they are expected to act in the best interest of the public; to deliver a product free of defects which can harm an individual or persons; and to make good on that responsibility if their products are defective. These can include faulty auto brakes, contaminated baby food, exploding bottles of beer, flammable children's pajamas, or lack of label warnings. The key element in products liability law is that a person who suffers harm from a product need not prove negligence, since the negligence is "presumed" and the result is "strict liability" (absolute responsibility) on the seller, distributor and manufacturer. An injured......

Words: 3293 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Products Liability

...Products Liability Research Paper Tonya Bailey Strayer University LEG 500---Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance Professor Lynn Macbeth June 2, 2012 Products Liability Introduction As consumers, we purchase products that we feel are beneficial to us in some way or another. The products that we decide and choose to purchase are solely up to the individual. If there is a problem or accident that may occur a result with use of that product, then the consumer is liable. But producers and manufacturers are not exempt being that it is there product, and this is where legal liability issues occur. “Product liability refers to the responsibility of manufacturers for injuries and damages caused by their products” (Hellriegel & Slocum, 2011, pg. 52). In this paper, I will examine the Toyota Motor Company and how this company has been the subject of a product liability lawsuit. First, I describe the company and the product safety issue that led to the lawsuit. Next, I will discuss the legal theories used by the plaintiff to recover in this lawsuit, how the lawsuit was resolved, and why I agree with the decision in the case. Then, it will be relevant to mention the changes that have taken place in the company to ensure greater safety of this product or its products, including specific policies that the company has put in place to protect consumers and end users who purchase and use its product. Afterwards, I will discuss the regulatory agency that oversees the......

Words: 773 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Products Liability Research Paper

...Products Liability Research Paper Select a company that has been the subject of a product liability lawsuit in the last ten (10) years. The Plaintiffs vs. Bayer Pharmaceuticals, the German manufacturer of the birth controls Yaz and Yasmin has landed themselves in hot water and is headed to the courts. Bayer Pharmaceuticals net worth is over a billion dollars and is still climbing. The use of the birth controls Yaz and Yasmin has sparked a lot of attention with claims of a number of dangerous side effects. This case has become very popular, with over 11,300 claims pending and the possibility of more to come, Bayer is expected to pay out about $110 Million in the Yaz case in an attempt to avoid being tried before a jury but that is only the beginning of a long list of active claims. The use of these birth controls are causing an increased number of blood clots in women as well as complications of blood disorders, problems of the heart, strokes, and in some cases even death. the problem appears to be stemming from drospirenone (a progestin) that is found in the birth control pills. In the case of Shannon Landry of Louisiana she filed a complaint with the U.S. district Court for the Southern District of Illinois. In 2000 Landry began taking Yaz and continued until 2010, and shortly thereafter she began having severe side effects. She was later diagnosed with a gallbladder disease called biliary dyskinesia that resulted in surgery to have her gallbladder......

Words: 2128 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking in the Legal Environment: Torts and Product Liability

...Critical Thinking in the Legal Environment: Torts and Product Liability Fall 2009 Introduction This assignment focuses on management skills that would be utilized in critical thinking in the legal environment specifically related to torts and product liability. A manager is constantly challenged with balancing responsibilities to the shareholders to make a profitable business and protecting the best interests of the employees and customers or end users of their products/services. This is especially challenging in large geographically diverse organizations, such as a McDonalds or car dealerships, where having statistical descriptive data, clear understanding of the policies, up and down the organization, and ensuring no significant information is being omitted is critical to running the company and avoiding lawsuits. A manager must be able to effectively analyze and evaluate data to make informed, intelligent decisions in many different situations. They need to be able to evaluate the reasons, without biases, in order to make sound decisions for the organization, as well as their employees and customers. There are lessons learned from the cases reviewed this week for managers related to critical thinking based on the two cases that are the focus of this paper, Liebeck v. McDonald’s and Pearson v. Custom Cleaners. . Liebeck vs. McDonalds As a very controversial tort case, Liebeck vs. McDonalds was a closely followed by the news and legal community. This...

Words: 3185 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Product Recall and Associated Liability

...Product Recall and Associated Liability Professor Muse Business | 670 Legal environment Londone Williams February 4, 2014 Product liability has been a subject that can create issues within a business. There have been various businesses that have gone bankrupt as a result of product liability problems. It is important for a company to consider the risk and liabilities with great consequences. This paper will discuss the significance of product liability and the role retailers play. The product that will be discussed in this paper is the Lion Force boys Puffer coat. The Puffer Coat, was recalled February 4, 2014, the recall number is 14-100. The Puffer Coat was recalled due to hazardous strangulation of children. The Puffer Coat was made in China, and as with many other products, is imported into the United States. “They typical product liability case involves a defective product purchased by the plaintiff who was subsequently injured by the product” (Kluwer, 2007). The goal of the United States Consumer Safety Commission is to guard the public from irrational possibility to injuries connected with consumer products. The U.S. Consumer Safety Commission’s function is to observe corrective plans that are known as recalls. There are more than 300 recalls each year from different manufacturers and distributors. Some of the recalls that are made are done because the Consumer Safety Commission determines that a product is faulty. In......

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Wisconsin Product Liabilities Paper

...Wisconsin Product Liability Laws According to Find Law, a website dedicated to helping people find lawyers, “Defective or dangerous products are the cause of thousands of injuries every year in the U.S.” (Find Law, n.d.). If people are getting injured because of defective products, there must be some kind of legislation that protects consumers. Product liability laws are laws that were created so that people who are injured from a defective product can sue to recover damages. Keep in mind that a defective product does not simply mean that the product is broken. The Business Dictionary says that a defective product is “unfit for its intended use, dangerous or harmful for normal use, does not carry adequate instructions for its use, or is inherently dangerous due to defective design, assembly, or manufacture” (Business Dictionary, n.d.). If a product is dangerous to use, why would people still use it? Sometimes the danger that lurks within a product is not visible, and unfortunately it takes someone getting hurt before anyone notices that something is wrong with it. It is these types of products that product liability laws protect us from. So then, whose laws protect us? During this class, we have learned that federal laws are the highest laws of the land. That means that if a crime is committed, state courts must follow federal laws if there is a law in place for that particular crime. What are the federal laws when it comes to product liability? There are none. Product......

Words: 3225 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Mgmt 520 Week 3 Homework

...Andrea Grigsby MGMT 520 Week 3 Homework You will be able to upload both attachments in the same Dropbox. The Dropbox allows you to attach multiple documents in the same submission. Failure to submit your shepardized case will result in a loss of 10 points. You will not be able to submit it after your assignment has been graded. Your assignment is due by Sunday, end of Week 3, 11:59 p.m. (MT). (Note: You will not submit anything to the Homework CASE Dropbox. Questions 1-6: Week 3 Homework answers (there are 6 questions total). While viewing the Nadel v. Burger King & Emil case answer the following questions: 1. What court decided the case in the assignment? (2 points) Answer: Court of Appeals Ohio, First District, Hamilton County 2. What must a party establish to prevail on a motion for summary judgment? (3 points) Answer: In order to prevail on a motion for summary judgment, a movant has the burden to demonstrate that no genuine issue of material fact remains to be litigated; that is entitled to judgment as a matter of law, and that it appears from the evidence, when viewed most strongly in favor of the nonmoving party, that reasonable minds can come to but tone conclusion and that conclusion is adverse to the non-moving party. The movant in this case would be the Nadel family. Nadel v. Burger King Corp., 1997 WL 266762 (Ct. App, 1st Dist., Ohio) 3. Briefly – state the facts of this case, using the information found in the case in LexisNexis.......

Words: 1284 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Hot Coffee

...Consumers Injured by Hot Coffee Can Seek Recovery Zachary Rami Follow this and additional works at: Part of the Consumer Protection Law Commons Recommended Citation Zachary Rami Courts Split as to Whether Consumers Injured by Hot Coffee Can Seek Recovery, 10 Loy. Consumer L. Rev. 310 (1998). Available at: This Case Note is brought to you for free and open access by LAW eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Loyola Consumer Law Review by an authorized administrator of LAW eCommons. For more information, please contact CASE NOTES Courts split as to whether consumers injured by hot coffee can seek recovery by Zachary Rami Common sense, coffee and consumers clashed recently in McMahon v. Bunn-O-Matic,l wherein the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals held that a coffee maker manufacturer did not have a duty to warn consumers that its coffee would be served at 180 degrees, and that the coffee maker was not defectively designed. The decision, which affirmed a lower court's entry of summary judgment in favor of the coffee maker manufacturer, is consistent with a majority of courts, which have held in recent years that such claims leave no issue of material fact for trial.' However, not every jurisdiction has routinely dismissed these "coffee" cases. In fact, McMahon referred to Nadel v. Burger King,3 which held that a products liability claim for excessively hot coffee was......

Words: 3301 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Hot Coffee

...absurd cases have worn down the underlying goodness of lawsuits. Along these lines, the potential for lawsuits to better the economy has dependably been there; be that as it may, the control of it and obvious cases of eagerness have debased its once honorable expectations to distraction individuals into examining the authenticity of each case. I think for this situation it would appear that anything goes and our law system promotes negligible laws. I think this would even fall into the categorization of trivial in light of the fact that the espresso was spilt by the offended party onto herself and not by the worker of where she purchased her espresso, and everybody realizes that espresso is hot! I think this case brand American considers our legal system and how far individuals can really go. . Frivolous is defined as a lawsuit that has no justification or merit. It is a case of evidence from one private gather against another. Components to consider prior to filing a lawsuit are: for a law suit to be classified as frivolous according to the law there must be no legal justification for delivery the suit and no conceivable law on which the suit could be based. Ethical thoughtfulness encompassing such law suits in the healthcare scene of action are that we must know and be aware of people’s intent and we ought to dependably endeavor to act and be ethical to our consumer so that there won't so that there won’t be a need for frivolous law suits again. Reference: Huang, P. H.......

Words: 396 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Is535 - Homework Es

...MIS – Homework ES Week 1 1. An information system can be defined technically as a set of interrelated components that collect (or retrieve), process, store, and distribute information to support: (Points: 2)        Decision making and control in an organization.        Communications and data flow.        Manager's analyzing the organization raw data.        The creation of new products and services. 2. The fundamental set of assumptions, values and ways of doing things that has been accepted by most of a company's members is called its: (Points: 2)        Culture        Environment        Atmosphere        Values 3. Networking and telecommunications technologies, along with computer hardware, software, data management technology, and the people required to run and manage them, constitute an organization's: (Points: 2)        Data management environment        Networked environment        IT infrastructure        Information system 4. Key corporate assets are: (Points: 2)        Intellectual property, core competencies, and financial and human assets.        Production technologies and business processes for sales, marketing, and finance.        Knowledge and the firm's tangible assets, such as goods and services.        Time and knowledge. 5. A managerial element in the UPS tracking system described in the chapter is: (Points: 2)        Taking inventory        Providing package status reports to customers        The......

Words: 2610 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Mcdonald's Hot Coffee Case

...Remaining relevant in a health conscious society Reference Code: ML00001-040 Publication Date: January 2012 WWW.MARKETLINEINFO.COM MARKETLINE. THIS PROFILE IS A LICENSED PRODUCT AND IS NOT TO BE PHOTOCOPIED MCDONALD’S CORPORATION CASE STUDY © MARKETLINE THIS PROFILE IS A LICENSED PRODUCT AND IS NOT TO BE PHOTOCOPIED ML00001-040/Published 01/2012 Page | 1 OVERVIEW Catalyst McDonald's Corporation is one of the world's largest foodservice retailing chains. The company is primarily known for its burgers and fries, which it sells through more than 32,000 restaurants in 117 countries. In 2010, the company served an average of 64 million customers per day. It primarily operates in Europe, Asia Pacific, and the Americas. The company is headquartered in Oak Brook, Illinois and employs about 400,000 people. McDonald’s has been able to successfully increase revenues and profits in recent years in spite of much negative publicity and an increasingly health conscious public. This case study shows how the company has achieved these goals in a difficult trading environment. Summary  McDonald’s has, to a great extent, defied recent difficult economic conditions and continued to experience strong sales and profit growth in recent years, as it has been able to attract diners with an improved and expanded product range while remaining competitive on price.  McDonald’s has been the target of much criticism in recent years for serving large amounts of foods high in......

Words: 5429 - Pages: 22

Free Essay

Product Liability

...Product Liability BUS:311 Instructor Samantha Hodapp November 28, 2011 Product Liability 1. Thesis a. As a consumer, you make product purchases on a consistent basis. Once you make your purchases, you are responsible for what happens to those purchases. However, the producers of these products are not completely free from accountability once their product is bought. This is where the term product liability comes into play. During this paper, I will explore the legal aspects of product liability and how it affects businesses. 2. What is product liability? b. According to our text, product liability is the accountability of a producer or seller for injury to buyers, users, and third parties. There are four elements that need to exist in order for the claimant to prove negligence by the manufactuer. These elements are duty, breach, proximate cause, and damages (Liuzzo & Bonnice, 2007). c. The bases for injury claims under product liability consists of product flaw, failure to warn, and design defect. These three characteristics generally become the foundation of claims filed against manufacturers (Liuzzo & Bonnice, 2007). 3. Who can be held liable for injuries caused by products? a. Manufacturers of products are not the only party that can be held liable for a product defect. Other parties that could be held liable include retailers, wholesalers, parts manufacturers, assembly workers, product endorsers, etc. Retailers are most......

Words: 567 - Pages: 3

2x Elbphilharmonie Hamburg THE GOLDEN VIOLIN 12.02.2019 | Hotspot Shield Elite download | Escape Plan 2: ...