Nucor at a Crossroads

In: Business and Management

Submitted By foym
Words 3362
Pages 14
Nucor at a Crossroads

MGMT XXXX-XXX

Nucor’s Historic Performance, Competitive Advantage, and Five Forces Analysis

With roots dating back to 1904 in the automobile manufacturing industry, Nucor’s business strategy has morphed many times over the course of the past century in response to struggling sales and unrealized business strategies. Since F. Kenneth Iverson’s appointment as Nucor’s President in 1965, however, Nucor has performed very well. With a focus on efficiency, Nucor is committed to minimizing bureaucracy and maximizing performance and productivity via the utilization of an open-door/continuous improvement/ entrepreneurial culture, a compensation scheme premised on performance-based incentives, and — last, but not least —commitment to technological advancement. With this approach, in an industry with 36 different companies, Nucor enjoyed the second largest market share in 1986, with 16 plants and an annual production capacity of 2.1 million tons of steel. In 1985, Nucor was ranked the most productive steel-maker in the United States and the second most productive in the world, averaging 981 tons per employee, per year. Nucor managed to achieve this success using a low-cost strategy, which proved to be particularly suitable in the highly competitive, commodity-like steel industry.

Despite its positive performance, competition in the U.S. steel industry was keen in 1986. At that time, the industry had sustained seven straights years of decreasing domestic demand, falling 22 percent since 1979 — but still demanding 90 million tons annually. Mini-mills accounted for 16 percent of domestic steel capacity, up from seven percent in 1975. Meanwhile, integrated steel-makers, although a major competitive force, were plagued by the complexity of their steel-making process as displayed in Exhibit 3 of the case, their own failure to invest in new…...

Similar Documents

Nucor at a Crossroads

...STANDER III Nucor en la encrucijada El 7 de diciembre de 1986, F. Kenneth Iverson, presidente y consejero delegado de Nucor Corporation, esperaba, en la oficina principal de su compañía en Charlotte, Carolina del Norte, la llegada de una delegación de SMS Schloemann-Siemag, líder fabricante germano-occidental de equipos para la obtención de acero. Iverson debía decidir si su compañía erigía una nueva planta siderúrgica para comercializar la nueva tecnología de colada continua de planchón delgado desarrollada por SMS. Los cálculos preliminares señalaban que sólo la fábrica costaría unos 280 millones de dólares, y que los gastos de puesta en marcha y el capital circulante, unos 30 millones de dólares cada concepto, elevarían el coste total a unos 340 millones de dólares, casi el patrimonio neto de Nucor. El éxito en la comercialización de la nueva tecnología representaría para Nucor la introducción en el sector de planos de acero, que suponía la mitad del total del mercado de acero en Estados Unidos. No obstante, el procedimiento SMS de colada de planchón delgado era una de las diversas tecnologías que competía en el mercado, todavía no lanzada comercialmente, y que sería probablemente superada, al igual que el resto de la tecnología, por otras nuevas tecnologías antes de fin de siglo. Además de sopesar todos estos factores, Iverson debía revisar el estado de la competencia en la industria del acero estadounidense y la posición específica que ocupaba......

Words: 13759 - Pages: 56

Nucor

...University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Master of Science in Organizational Dynamics Theses 1-31-2007 Organizational Dynamics Programs Nucor Corporation: A Study on Evolution Toward Strategic Fit Regina Gordin University of Pennsylvania, regina.gordin@gmail.com Submitted to the Program of Organizational Dynamics In the Graduate Division of the School of Arts and Sciences In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Organizational Dynamics at the University of Pennsylvania. Advisor: Everett Keech This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. http://repository.upenn.edu/od_theses_msod/1 For more information, please contact repository@pobox.upenn.edu. NUCOR CORPORATION: A STUDY ON EVOLUTION TOWARD STRATEGIC FIT by Regina Gordin Submitted to the Program of Organizational Dynamics In the Graduate Division of the School of Arts and Sciences In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Organizational Dynamics at the University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 2006 NUCOR CORPORATION: A STUDY ON EVOLUTION TOWARD STRATEGIC FIT Approved by: ________________________________________________ Program Director ________________________________________________ Advisor ABSTRACT For much of its century long history, Nucor Corporation and its predecessors displayed turbulent financial performance. Several attempts at a strategic realignment proved unsuccessful, and......

Words: 18185 - Pages: 73

Nucor

...University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Master of Science in Organizational Dynamics Theses 1-31-2007 Organizational Dynamics Programs Nucor Corporation: A Study on Evolution Toward Strategic Fit Regina Gordin University of Pennsylvania, regina.gordin@gmail.com Submitted to the Program of Organizational Dynamics In the Graduate Division of the School of Arts and Sciences In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Organizational Dynamics at the University of Pennsylvania. Advisor: Everett Keech This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. http://repository.upenn.edu/od_theses_msod/1 For more information, please contact repository@pobox.upenn.edu. NUCOR CORPORATION: A STUDY ON EVOLUTION TOWARD STRATEGIC FIT by Regina Gordin Submitted to the Program of Organizational Dynamics In the Graduate Division of the School of Arts and Sciences In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Organizational Dynamics at the University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 2006 NUCOR CORPORATION: A STUDY ON EVOLUTION TOWARD STRATEGIC FIT Approved by: ________________________________________________ Program Director ________________________________________________ Advisor ABSTRACT For much of its century long history, Nucor Corporation and its predecessors displayed turbulent financial performance. Several attempts at a strategic realignment proved unsuccessful, and......

Words: 18185 - Pages: 73

Nucor

...MGMT – 702-101 Nucor Case Study Instructor: James Farmer By, Arulraj Rajaram – 300729443 Strategic Management Date: 29th July, 2013 Page |2 1) Rolled steel is a commoditized product. Commoditized products are extremely difficult to differentiate and distinguish (in terms of marketing and sales methods) from your competitor’s products. Name and explain at least three strategies that Nucor Corporation has employed to differentiate its products and services, from its competitors. A) Nucor Corporation has employed various strategies to differentiate its products and services, from its competitors over the years. They have differentiated their products and services so well that they offer steel users with a wide range of steel products. The three strategies that Nucor has employed are: Low Cost of Production Strategy: Nucor constantly worked on attaining low cost of production by improving their production efficiency. Nucor constantly made investments in modernization of their plants, and new technology in the production of steel. They adopted automated technology that helped in fewer requirements of employees to operate. Thereby, increasing the productivity of labor and decreasing the cost. Nucor also employed electric arc furnaces and fewer production steps which lead to low energy costs. Also, the management system of Nucor was designed in a way that led to increased innovation by the employees and quick decision making. All these practices helped Nucor to have a......

Words: 903 - Pages: 4

Crossroads

...THOSE CROSSROADS THAT LET ME BE It is not too often that one is at that point when a crucial decision must be made; never too frequently that one is faced with a situation, which will have far-reaching life consequences. True, that for 23 years it never happened too customarily to me. But during those times they did, I felt, really, that I was standing in the middle of crossroads… feeling blank, empty and hollow. I was there standing. I came to a fork in the path and I was faced with the challenge of making the right decision. It was an opportunity for that inevitable change to strike my career, blow my happiness and shake my life. I knew I had to make them. I needed to; for by this chance, I am changing my always and shape them to what others say destiny. In looking back at those journeys I have taken, I am struck by the marginal crossroads I had to stand at. Each, I have gotten my feet one after another. These crossroads made me and surely let me be. And I will share them accordingly. First, I chose a pre-med course despite my intention to be that lawyer who I should’ve been. My folks nipped the budding lawyer in me because of its question on nobility as a profession. They grew the doctor in me instead. Their reason… they think it may grant us all sure slots in heaven… extending, saving lives. I ranted. I whined. But I was still the one who made that decision after all. So I had to do what I got to do. And I discovered it was not so bad. It was never bad at......

Words: 537 - Pages: 3

Nucor

...Nucor Corporation (A) We are a cyclical business... Basically when you are at the peak of the cycle—times are good, interest rates are low, people are building—our margins increase. When we go to the trough, of course, the margins are squeezed. But over the last 25 years Nucor has never had a losing quarter. Not only a losing quarter, we have never had a losing month or a losing 1 week. —John D. Correnti, President and CEO, Nucor In 1998, Nucor was a Fortune 500 company with 6,900 employees and had sales of $4.3 billion in steel and steel-related products. Its chairman, F. Kenneth Iverson, had headed the company for more than 30 years. During his tenure, the steel industry faced a number of problems, including foreign competition, strained labor relations, and slowed demand for steel (related in part to the substitution of alternative materials). Despite these industry challenges, Nucor’s sales during Iverson’s tenure grew at an annual compound rate of about 17 percent per annum. Selected comparative financial data are shown in Exhibit 1. In different years, both Iverson and Nucor CEO John Correnti were named Steelmaker of the Year by New Steel magazine. History Nucor traced its origins to auto manufacturer Ransom E. Olds, who founded Oldsmobile and, later, Reo Motor Cars. Through a series of transactions, the company Olds founded eventually became the Nuclear Corporation of America, a company involved in the nuclear instrument and electronics business in the 1950’s......

Words: 5761 - Pages: 24

Nucor in 2009

...Title of the Case: Nucor in 2009 Time Context or Period: 1905-2009 of Nucor Summary of the Case: In 1905, Ransom E. Olds, creator of the Oldsmobile, had a dispute with stockholders and left his own company — Olds Motor Works. He soon formed REO Motor Company, which evolved into the Nuclear Corporation of America and ultimately, Nucor. In 1962, this was the year that Nuclear Corporation made two moves that would soon change the company and ultimately the American steel industry. First, they acquired a company called Vulcraft, an unassuming producer of steel joists and girders. Second, to run Vulcraft, they hired a man named Ken Iverson who would soon emerge as one of the great visionaries and mavericks in American industry. Barely staving off bankruptcy, Nuclear appointed Ken Iverson as its new president. He acted quickly to put the company on a course toward profitability including selling off inefficient divisions. Not long after we shed our conglomerate business model to become a highly focused steel producer, The board of directors elected to change the name of the company from Nuclear Corporation of America to simply Nucor. Since then, Nucor has contributed over 70 million dollars to Scholarships and Educational Disbursements. It is a source for millions of dollars for educational funding. To this day, every child of every Nucor teammate is entitled to educational funds from the company. Now, Nucor is one of the leading steel producers in the United States.......

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Nucor

...INTRODUCTION Decisions form the basis of strategy. Each firm must make choices regarding what resources and capabilities to invest in, as well as what to do with such resources and capabilities in order to achieve sustainable competitive advantage. The star of this week’s case, Nucor Steel, finds itself at a critical inflexion point: Should it invest in a new steel mill to commercialize thin-slab casting? This paper examines why Nucor is considering making such an investment and what risks are involved if they choose to adopt the technology. Based on this analysis, the paper will conclude with a recommended path for Nucor Steel. YOU CAN NEVER BE TOO RICH OR TOO THIN The flat sheet segment accounts for 52% of the U.S. market for steel. The large integrated steel mills such as U.S. Steel, LTV Steel, and Bethlehem Steel dominate this important segment. Minimills such as Nucor are shut out of the flat sheet market because with conventional steel-making technology, the minimum efficient scale for flat sheet production is too high, with optimal capacities for each plant reaching 3 million tons per year and investment costs close to $2 billion. In contrast, minimills typically only produce 800,000 to 1 million tons per year, with investment levels closer to $300 million. The cost advantages from thin-slab casting are substantial. If viable, thin-slab casting minimills could become a category killer in the flat sheet segment. For hot rolled flat sheets, the operating costs per ton......

Words: 1878 - Pages: 8

Nucor

...Nucor Corporation: Competing against Low-Cost Steel Imports SWOT, PESTEL, Success Factor and Competitive Advantages Analysis Course Title: Strategic Management Course Code: FNB 309 Prepared For Hare Krisna Kundo Lecturer Department of Public Administration Prepared By Name | Student Id | Md. Shohag Ali | 1265 | Md. Khairul Islam | 1286 | Md. Nazrul Islam | 1292 | Md. Waish Hasan | 1295 | Nawshad Haque | 1959 | BBA, First BatchDept. of Finance and Banking | Date of Submission: September 6, 2012 Department of Finance & Banking Jahangirnagar University Savar, Dhaka-1342 * Problem Statement * Right now Nucor’s main problem is an excess of steel in the market. Foreign steel is being dumped in US, the market is flooded and supply exceeds demand. This decreases the steel companies’ profits and puts pressure on them, forcing some of them into bankruptcy. * Another problem they face is lack of innovation of technology. In order for Nucor to maintain, and continue to post profits in the future they must identify areas to increase technology to lower production costs and increase throughput. * Solution To Problem Statement: Chronologically * Nucor Corporation General Information * Timeline of History and Development * Industry Analysis * Primary Competitive Forces * Driving forces * PESTEL * Porter’s Five Forces Model * Failure of US Market in 2005 ...

Words: 3081 - Pages: 13

Compsis at a Crossroads

...07-044 Rev. December 15, 2009 This case was prepared by lecturer M. Jonathan Lehrich and MIT Sloan students Paul John Paredes and Ramesh Ravikumar (MBA Class of 2005). Copyright © 2007, M. Jonathan Lehrich, Paul John Paredes and Ra mesh Ravikumar. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No De rivative Works 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license visit http://creativecommons.org /licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA. Compsis at a Crossroads M. Jonathan Lehrich, Paul John Paredes, Ramesh Ravikumar 2004 had not been a good year for Compsis. Founded in 1989 in the Brazilian industrial city of São José dos Campos, Compsis had grown steadily and su ccessfully. In its largest service line, systems integration for electronic toll collection (ETC), th e company had gained the dominant share of the Brazilian market and had even managed projects in Australia and India. Compsis had developed strong relationships with the Brazilian government a nd toll road operators, as well as an international reputation among industry competitors for quality and technological expertise. By 2003, the company’s founders could take pride in reach ing a height of 165 employees and US$4.2 million (R$11.1 million) in revenue. In 2004, however, it appeared that Compsis’s success might be in jeopardy. Revenue fell to US$3.3 million,......

Words: 969 - Pages: 4

Nucor

...  Ques1: ECV Fit for Nucor Environment • Outdated technology, rising cost competitive imports, and unfavourable labour costs and contracts resulting in restructuring in the industry – job cuts and capacity cuts • Initially minimills produced low end structural products enjoyed various advantages such a decline in demand for scrap metal (a critical input for them) from integrated players, reduction in minimal efficient scale of production and capital cost per ton of capacity by a factor of 10, closer to market locations • Currently minimills have expanded their product base (to high end products) and geographic focus, thereby resulting in break-down of geographic insulation. This resulted in reduction in volume growth, which reached single digits in 1980s • Reorganization and buy-outs of other mini-mills in the face of changing environment • R&D going on for evaluation of various alternative casting technologies. None proved commercially feasible yet Company • Faced tough times until the hiring of CEO Ken Iverson in 1962. He decided to divest most of the businesses and focus on the core steel business. He has also risked to build company’s modern minimill in Darlington in 1962 • Two pillars of success: Build steel plants economically and operate them efficiently • Second most productive steel maker globally • Flat hierarchical structure with only 5 layers of management, with clear distinctions of roles, responsibilities and autonomy. Capital budgeting - top......

Words: 1539 - Pages: 7

Nucor at a Crossroads

...Nucor at a Crossroads Case Analysis In 1986, three distinct segments defined the U.S. steel industry; integrated steel mills, mini-mills, and specialty steel makers. The integrated mills have the capacity to produce a maximum of 107 million tons of steel per year, mini-mills produced a maximum of 21 million tons of capacity a year, and the nation’s specialty steel makers could produce a maximum capacity of 5 million tons of stainless and specialty grades of steel. This leads to a total capacity of 133 million tons of production per year. In 1986, the market consumed only 70 million tons of steel, leaving 33 million tons unused. Nucor is at a crossroads. It faces a saturated market suffering from significant overcapacity. Nucor’s only opportunity for growth seems to be to expand into the production of flat sheet metal. However, to compete in that area, Nucor would need to invest in a very risky new technology, a thin-slab casting plant that, if successful, would allow Nucor to manufacture flat sheet metal with a low minimum efficient scale and a low marginal cost of production. This case will examine Nucor’s history, the impacts of entering the thin-slab casting business, the advantages Nucor would reap, and whether they should build the new thin-slab casting plant. Looking at the business landscape of the steel industry, it is amazing to see how well Nucor has done considering the industry is so competitive and has relatively low profitability. Using Porter’s...

Words: 1363 - Pages: 6

Nucor

...NUCOR CORPORATION (A) 1. Why has Nucor performed so well? a. Is Nucor’s industry the answer? b. Is it the “mini-mill” effect? c. Is it market power (scale economies)? d. Is it a distribution channel advantage? e. Is it a raw material advantage? f. Is it a technology advantage? g. Is it a location advantage? h. Is it the result of an entrenched brand name? i. Is it Nucor’s choice of a unique strategy? j. Is it Nucor’s ability to execute its strategy? Ada beberapa poin utama yang menjadi faktor utama keberhasilan dari Nucor yaitu dari adopsi mini mill. Beberapa keuntungan yang diperoleh adalah: i. Teknologi tungku busur listrik, sehingga biaya yang dikeluarkan lebih rendah, dan bahan baku yang digunakan adalah besi tua sehingga lebih murah. ii. Lokasi di pedesaan sehingga biaya tenaga kerja lebih rendah iii. Produk berkualitas 2. What are the most important aspects of Nucor’s overall approach to organization and control that help explain why this company is so successful? How well do Nucor’s organization and control mechanisms fit the company’s strategic requirements? Struktu organisasi yang dianut adalah system desentralisasi sehingga keputusan lebih cepat dan efektif, tidak harus menunggu keputusan dari kantor pusat. Hal tersebut juga memberikan kemungkinan penurunan biaya karena keputusan dapa cepat dibuat dan diimplementasikan. 3. A crucial element of......

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Nucor

...There are a few significant reasons Nucor has done really well in the past. Ken Iverson had a unique strategic vision for the administration of the workforce, optimizing operational efficiency of plants and making wise investment decisions overall. As a result, Nucor demonstrated superior capabilities by effectively using its resources to develop efficiencies in volume production, and bring products to market more cheaply and more quickly than its competitors. To begin, Nucor utilized a combination of research and development activities that advanced the speed and efficiency of its production process. The company invested heavily and steadily in its capacity and made serious efforts to embody technological advances. Nucor was able to lower its overall costs using their extensive experience in building and remodeling minimills in ways other firms were unable to imitate. Not only Nucor has been able to start up its steel mills within 18 months of groundbreaking, but also it had the speed of delivery to customers and suppliers by locating mills in similar geographic regions. Without a doubt, Nucor was the low cost- high efficiency leader in the market. In addition, the workforce was held accountable for the performance of the business at all levels. The company decentralized as many decisions down to the plant as possible but held managers accountable for an annual contribution of 25% of the net assets employed at that plant. The workers also received......

Words: 548 - Pages: 3

Nucor

...Nucor at Cross Roads - Swot Hbr Case Week 3: Nucor at Crossroads Strengths * Strong leadership & progressive company culture => decentralized management philosophy, egalitarian benefits, performance based compensation, strong emphasis on customer service and quality, and technological leadership through consistent investment in R&D and modernization of plant & machinery * Strong financials => consistent growth in sales and profits during the last 3 years (1983 to 1985) with the most recent year (1986) resulting in a sales figure of $755Mn (down $3Mn from last year) and net earnings of $46Mn. * Flat structure => leading to improved communication (formal & informal) between corporate and factory and amongst factories (interplant) => leading to improved efficiencies / productivity * High employee morale, low staff turnover compared to industry average => a culture that promotes Is this essay helpful? Join OPPapers to read more and access more than 650,000 just like it! get better grades team work, high levels of commitment and hard work => compensation schemes designed to reinforce the relationship between pay and performance and to reward production groups rather than individual performance. Also attractive incentive and reward schemes for employees (eg. bonuses, stock options, health coverage, college education for children of employees). * Nucor’s geographic spread (by 1986 Nucor had 16 plants in 10......

Words: 299 - Pages: 2

The Walking Dead No Man's Land paid | Lot of 10 Morgan Design 1 Oz .999 Fine Silver Rounds SKU31048$180.85 19d left | Cities Skylines Update v1.06-CODEX