Police Discretion Case Analysis

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Albeiroflorez
Words 2424
Pages 10
Police Discretion Case Analysis
Albeiro E. Florez
Law Enforcement Administration
CCJS 340
Due by 13 October 2013

Author Note
Albeiro E. Florez, Department of Criminal Justice, University of Maryland University College.
This report is a response to Professor Jeffrey B. Bumgarner’s project 2 directives.
Correspondence concerning this report should be addressed to Albeiro E. Florez, Department of Criminal Justice, University of Maryland University College, Adelphi eCampus, Adelphi, MD 20783.
Contact: florezalbeiro87@gmail.com

Police Discretion Case Analysis People make decisions on a daily basis to decide what we should do in any given situation. Having the knowledge to differentiate between what is appropriate or inappropriate is what gives us the freedom to make this decision with the correct judgment. In law enforcement, sworn officers are taught to face any situation by employing good judgment and making the best decisions by themselves or with little to no supervision.
This is what we know as police discretion (The Rynard Law Firm, 2007). The Merriam-Webster dictionary describes discretion as “the quality of being careful about what you do and say so that people will not be embarrassed or offended” (Merriam-Webster, 2013).
Although systematic routines and protocols need to be followed by officers to ensure they abide by the law as well as to enforce it, often circumstances will show up and force officers to make a decision based on what they feel is right or wrong according to their training. Even though the Chiefs of police do not spend a lot of time in the field, they still have to use discretion while making decision that affects the police department and the community.
As I finished reading and understanding our textbook, I started to realize how complex police work can be, especially when we examine closely the use of discretion in the…...

Similar Documents

Explain Why Police Have Lots of Discretion with Juveniles

...Explain why police have lots of discretion with juveniles? give examples! Introduction In recent years there has been growing concern about the incidence and seriousness of juvenile offending. This concern has not been unwarranted. Statistics gathered for the Sourcebook of Criminal Justice indicated a significant increase in the number of juvenile arrests, from year to year, during the late 1980’s and throughout the early 1990’s. One snapshot, in 1996, revealed that the number of juvenile arrests that year represented a 35 percent increase over 1987 while arrests overall had increased only 13 percent over the same time period (Sourcebook, 1997). The percent increase in juvenile arrests for ‘violent offenses’ was even greater over the same time period (see Worden and Myers (1999) “Police Encounters with Juvenile Suspects” report submitted to the National Research Council’s Panel on Juvenile Crime: Prevention, Treatment, and Control). In addition, media portrayals of juvenile crime as increasing in frequency and seriousness, while not entirely accurate, affect public sentiment about juvenile troublemakers and about what might constitute appropriate responses from the juvenile justice system. Despite evidence of a decline in the number of juvenile arrests as well as evidence of an overall decline in juvenile crime since the mid 1990’s (Lynch 2002), public and political concern about juvenile offending remains high. Evidence of this sentiment is noted by the nationwide......

Words: 568 - Pages: 3

Case Analysis

...Case 11.1- Mazda and Syzygy Case Overview Mazda Motor Europe hired an observational company by the name of Syzygy to monitor the consumers that uses their website. Situation Analysis Mazda Motor Europe would like to know details about how consumers are using their website and if the website is user friendly. Questions 1. What could Mazda learn from eye-tracking software that would be difficult to learn? from other observational methods? The eye-tracking software provides Mazda with the ability to observe eye movement and track the amount of time spent looking at a particular area. 2. What are the shortcomings of this method? The shortcomings of using the eye tracking software method are: • The equipment is expensive • Some users can't work with the equipment • Calibrating the equipment takes time 3. Along with the eye-tracking research, what other research methods could help Mazda assess the usability of its website? Summarize your advice for how Mazda could use complementary methods to obtain a complete understanding of its website’s usability. Questionnaires are an effective way of quantifying data from a sample group, and testing emotions or preferences. This method is very cheap and easy, where budget is a problem, and gives an element of scale to opinion and emotion. These figures are arbitrary, but at least give a directional method of measuring intensity. Case 11.2- Texas Instruments and E-Lab Case Overview Texas Instruments......

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Case Analysis

... 19a. NAME OF RESPONSIBLE PERSON unclassified unclassified unclassified Same as Report (SAR) 176 Standard Form 298 (Rev. 8-98) Prescribed by ANSI Std Z39-18 TABLE OF CONTENTS NCIS REPORTING & MILITARY JUSTICE INVESTIGATIONS...........................................................................1 HANDLING SEXUAL ASSAULT ALLEGATIONS IN THE USMC.......................................................................3 SUSPECTS—QUESTIONING/INTERROGATION/ ARTICLE 31(b) ....................................................................5 SEARCH & SEIZURE.............................................................................................................................................7 SEARCH & SEIZURE – DRUG CASES ................................................................................................................9 COURTS-MARTIAL: TYPES & CONVENING ....................................................................................................12 COURTS-MARTIAL: BASICS..............................................................................................................................14 COURTS-MARTIAL: PRETRIAL RESTRAINT (PTR) ........................................................................................16 PRETRIAL AGREEMENTS........................................................................................................................ 18 COURTS-MARTIAL: POST- TRIAL......

Words: 39456 - Pages: 158

Case Analysis

...KREATIVE KASUALS INC. In July 2010, Gary Masters started his monthly review of government tenders to determine whether there were any that he would like to bid on. Masters was the owner and president of Kreative Kasuals Inc., a textiles manufacturer based in Scarborough, Ontario. The company primarily supplied the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services (the Ministry) with coveralls, shirts and boxers, as well as fabric used for internal production. There were two tenders that were of interest to Masters. One involved supplying washable trousers to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), and the other was a tender for uniform dress shirts and cargo pants for the Ministry. KREATIVE KASUALS INC. Kreative Kasuals Inc. (Kreative) was established in 1995, when Masters was in his early 40s. Kreative began its operations by offering contract sewing for running-shoe companies, retail stores and children’s wear manufacturers as a result of a business contact that offered an immediate and profitable opportunity. Kreative operated out of a 2,000-square-foot facility, with only a handful of mainly part-time employees. Initial jobs were small and were mainly one-off contracts, resulting in highly irregular work schedules and unstable revenues. Kreative’s first contract with the Ministry involved the supply of fabric for internal production, which meant Kreative acted essentially as a distributor of fabrics. This relationship eventually led to other contracts for......

Words: 2139 - Pages: 9

State Police High Performance Teams Analysis

...State Police High Performance Teams Analysis The State Police for any state uses the advances of a flexible, fluid interchanging operational structure. The State Police high performance teams become more than functioning officers behind the wheel of a police cruiser, at the controls of the helicopter, or underwater saving a child. Every high performance or learning team uses and involves group decisions for each situation may change at a moment’s notice. The elements for excellent high performance team-builds show in the supporting information. The advances of biometric, information, and electronic technology create the help each high performance, or learning organization needs for social survival. High Performance and Learning Team Elements The essential elements for building high performance police and learning teams begin three important stages; engaging, enabling, and energizing (Building Teamwork, 2012). The engaging stage defines first three elements as purpose, commitment, and trust. Starting with purpose for using the specialized team and goals. The reasoning foundation shows details for the operational support and resources for achieving the organizational goals. The commitment stage defines decisions of each individual in a team for becoming close-knit unit calmly working together. This collection of talented individuals agree to commit dedicated time, and training to achieve the goals for success. The importance of team trust shows a conscious commitment of......

Words: 2947 - Pages: 12

Florida Police Case

...Week 2 Thought Paper CJE4610 8/31/14 A case starts the moment the call is received. In many cases there is evidence or clues on the call itself. One of the things you can get from the call is a description of the incident, suspect information, and other various clues and information. Then when you get on scene your real investigation will begin. You may or may not have real life suspects or victims on scene. Once you get on scene you have to start processing information and the scene itself. You never know what clues you will get when you show up on scene. There are different types of evidence to collect when you process a scene. There is trace evidence, which includes hairs, fibers, glass and soil. The second is impression evidence, which includes fingerprints left on objects, and also palms, tires and cloth. The next kind of evidence is biological to include blood, teeth and skeletal remains. The fourth kind of evidence is firearms and weapons including the guns and ammunition. The last is probably the one that most people forget or disregard, are documents to include contracts, currency, passports, and other documents. In the case that was presented on page 126 there was a lot of evidence to be processed. The call originated as a disturbance from neighbors. The officers arrived and discovered a very disrupted house. From the pictures, there were obvious signs of a struggle with in the residence. So the description stated that when the officer arrived no one...

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Sunny Grove Police Control Case Study

...Sunny Grove Police Control Case Study Sean Karrels Webster University MNGT 5000 MANAGEMENT 2014 Dr. John Theodore February 15, 2014 Sunny Grove Police Control Case Study Anytime that a manager or executive takes over a new organization there is going to be change. To paraphrase Charles Darwin, it is not the strongest of species that survives, nor the most intelligent, but the one most responsive to change. (Rumsfeld, 2013) I would argue in this particular case that this is a perfect opportunity for any leader, by that I mean you are walking into an organization with challenges, but there is only 1 way to go and that’s up, that is a preverbal softball for any type A personality! Being a solid leader however is not enough to turn around any organization that has problems with the basic building blocks or to use a sports analogy, a football team that cannot block and tackle. In this analysis I am going to attempt to suggest some controls that can be used to improve the Sunny Grove Police Department for the present and future. Strategy First! I am going to start this out with a quote that I have used in previous case studies from Donald Rumsfeld to set the table for my opening argument in this analysis, I will get to managerial control, but I think as the new Chief of Police for Sunny Grove, my first step is going to establish a Strategy first, and get everyone on board and then transition to putting control systems in place for success. Strategy is a general plan of......

Words: 1153 - Pages: 5

Case Analysis

...optimization of its own strength and strategies, Lindo Enterprises will continue to maintain its position in the market and met its annual target growth rate in the next five years. II. Statement of the Problem... View Full Essay Join Now Please login to view the full essay... Essay's Statistics Submitted by: catherinepagdato Date shared: 11/19/2013 03:58 AM Words: 1276 Pages: 6 Save Paper Report this Essay Similar Documents Harley Case Analysis Case Analysis Outline a Case Analysis For “The Vidsoft Triangle (a)” Case Analysis Wengart Aircraft Case Toyota - Case Analysis Case Analysis Sports Company And Vietnam Case Analysis Case Analysis Case Analysis On Superior Grain Elevator Inc Clean Edge Razor Case Analysis Case Analysis Charlotte Beers (Ogilvy & Mather) Case Analysis Case Analysis: The Sundale Club Byd Case Analysis Jones Blair Case Analysis Global Expansion Strategies Of Two Korean Carmakers- Case Analysis Case Analysis Mfs Case Analysis Ben & Jerry's Case Analysis Sample Swot Case Analysis LoginJoin RSS ©2014 TermPaperWarehouse.com Privacy Policy Terms of Service Copyright Information Contact Us Help Advertise With Us...

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Police Discretion

...perspective discretion can be defined as the authority granted by law to agencies and officials to act on their own considered judgement and conscience in certain situations; and each area of the legal system (judges, parliament and law enforcement) has its own discretion. Police discretion is the ability granted by the legal system to police offices, in certain situations, to act in a manner that allows authorities to make responsible decisions and individual choices or judgments, within certain legal bounds. In law enforcement, discretion is left up to each individual officer to make reasonable and responsible decisions out in the field everyday (Beech, 2008). Discretion is used in many situations, such as when an officer chooses to stop a vehicle for a small traffic violation. There are also times when the officer has no choice but to use specific discretion in certain situations and make a decision on what type of force is necessary for certain situations (Elicker, 2007). Society believes that an officer can make any choice he or she chooses at anytime while on the job, which is highly incorrect as there are many situations when an officer has no choice but to follow the law. For the most part every officer has a choice when to use or not to use discretion, and enforce the law, but allowing this choice to be made by individuals, who may seem like an average member of society, can pose a real threat regarding the misuse of such power (Delattre, 2006). Police discretion......

Words: 2669 - Pages: 11

Police Case Study-Immigration Reform

...purposes and to authorize the cancellation of removal and adjustment of status of certain alien students who are long-term United States residents and who entered the United States as children, and for other purposes. Proponents say the act is a crucial measure for protecting undocumented youth, who did not choose to immigrate to the United States, while critics contend that it would encourage others to immigrate illegally with hopes of eventually obtaining permanent residence for their children. Conclusion Our nation's immigration policies must be consistent with humanitarian values and with the need to treat all individuals with respect and dignity. Any proposal that would criminalize undocumented immigrants, encourage state or local police to enforce immigration laws, or penalize individuals for providing humanitarian assistance to their fellow human beings must be strongly opposed. President Obama said he want Republicans and Democrats to work with him on creating a bill that satisfied both parties. Calling for compromise, the president acknowledged his critics and said every president of the last half century have taken similar actions on immigration. To those who said the president should not use executive power and work with Congress to pass reforms, Obama's message was "pass a bill." References (centered, not bold) Cohen, S. (January, 2013). The Huff Post Politics: The importance of immigration. Retrieved from URL: ......

Words: 1511 - Pages: 7

Police Discretion

...Assignment: Police Discretion CJS/210 I define discretion as being anytime one may make a decision. The decision may be anything as simple as what to wear that day to something as complicated as to whether or not to accept a job in a different state. Discretion is used many times in one day; one may not even realize that they are using discretion. Discretion is critical in law enforcement because it could be the difference between life and death either for the law enforcement officer himself or others. A law enforcement officer has to make split second decisions that can affect one’s life dramatically if the wrong decision is made; this is why it is important for the right decision to be made. Not only can the wrong decision cause death or serious injury, it can also cause one’s life to be torn upside down if a wrong arrest is made. The officer in the scenario exercised discretion in these three ways. First the officer used discretion when she decided to stop and provide medical care if needed, by deciding to approach the suspect instead of driving on discretion was used. Second, the officer used discretion by deciding to chase after the suspect when he ran away. Third, the officer exercised discretion when she chased after the suspect again even though a violent struggle had occurred instead of calling for back up first. I believe that the officer did use appropriate discretion; however I believe that she could have saved herself a lot of trouble and pain if she...

Words: 402 - Pages: 2

Case Analysis

...MKT 533 Branding Strategy Cases Dr. Diane Badame Fall 2015 The price of this reader reflects a 20% discount on production costs, due to the early submittal of material by the instructor. Dear Student: Reproduction of copyrighted material, without prior permission of the copyright owner, particularly in an educational setting, is an issue of concern for the academic community. Unfortunately, the impropriety of much unauthorized copying is all too often overlooked by users in an educational setting. Although copying all or part of a work without obtaining permission may appear to be an easy and convenient solution to an immediate problem, such unauthorized copying can frequently violate the rights of the author or publisher of the copyrighted work, and be directly contrary to the academic mission to teach respect for ideas and the intellectual property that expresses those ideas. With that in mind, the University Bookstore has sought permission and paid royalties for all materials enclosed. The price of your reader reflects those necessary costs. This material comes from "Questions and Answers on Copyright for the Campus Community," Copyright 1993 by National Association of College Stores, Inc. and the Association of American Publishers. MKT 533 – Branding Strategy Dr. Badame, Fall 2015 UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA MARSHALL GRADUATE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS MKT 533 – BRANDING STRATEGY 1.5 CREDIT COURSE FALL 2015 ___________________...

Words: 43234 - Pages: 173

Experiment Analysis in Increasing Productivity of Police Service Employees

...Experiment Analysis in Increasing Productivity of Police Service Employees Roger W. Clark University of Phoenix Research 320 Foundations of Research June 20, 2010 Experiment Analysis in Increasing Productivity of Police Service Employees Introduction In 1973, the city manager of Orange California is looking to boost the pay of police officers, without alienating the taxpayers. The city manager determined the police force is highly educated and intelligent allowing for the agreement of the incentive plan focusing on reducing reported crimes in the city. The experiment is designed to determine if an incentive pay program can increases police productivity. Indentifying the experiments control group, pilot group, independent variable, and dependent variables are essential to determining the experiment’s reliability and validity. Experiment The city of Orange California entered into agreement with the City of Orange Police Association to increase officers pay based on reported crimes in four categories, rape, burglary, robbery, and auto theft. Murder and assault were not included in the incentive plan because homicide and assault are considered a crime of passion, and larceny frequently involves theft from businesses (Staudohar, n.d., p. 520). The incentive plan could increase the agreed 7.5 percent pay increase in 1973 and six percent in 1974. The incentive increase for a reduction of 10% is an additional 2% and 3% for a reduction of 12% in reported crime......

Words: 838 - Pages: 4

Case Analysis

...Case Analysis Madison County v Kimberly McLaughlin Facts On September 12, 2009 Kimberly McLaughlin was charged with the murder of her mother. The facts of the case stand as such, on the morning of September 13, 2009, Shirley Robuck the mother of Kimberly McLaughlin was found in her burning home. Medical examiner determined that the victim was stabbed a minimum of 211 times before being decapitated and set on fire. Issues Defense for McLaughlin is arguing that the defendant is not guilty because of serious mental disease or defect. Defendant was found competent to stand trial, despite defense attorney’s stating she was not competent. “Under Alabama law the defendant's attorneys have to prove to a judge or a jury that she is not able to assist in her own defense and does not have a "reasonable degree of rational understanding" of the facts and the court proceeding” (Lawson, 2012, para. three). Decision The decision from the jury was the Kimberly McLaughlin was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of her mother in 2009 and found not guilty of arson charges that were filed along with the murder charges by Madison County. Reasoning The jury stated that the defense could not prove that the defendant was mentally ill or had mental defect. Opinion I have to disagree with the jury’s verdict on one side on the other the defense attorney should have worked harder to prove that the defendant suffered from mental illness. US v. Blagojevich Facts Rod......

Words: 771 - Pages: 4

Case Analysis

... Case Analysis Toyota Case Analysis   I. Viewpoint         For further analysis of this case, Ms. Rivera as a Marketing Manager is responsible to solve the dealing problem.   II. Time Context         In the year 1990’s different problem occurred.   Toyota reduced part defects by 84%. It also reduced the ratio of inventories to sales by 35% versus 6%. III. Objectives   a. To be able to implement the marketing strategy used in the said case.   b. To be able to have a good relation in dealing with consumers needs and wants.   c. To be able to maximize operating performance and financial returns to ensure growth for the company’s future.   d. To be able to classify the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats that the company have.   e. To be able to explain the solutions in the major problem of Toyota.   IV. Statement of the problem         Major:         Competition will arise. Toyota’s has a closest competitor regarding on its consumers – Ford motor vehicles and Mercedes. It is a problem on how they can implement their marketing strategy to stay on top amidst of the consumers demands.         Minor:   1. A reduction on ratio of inventories to sales by 35 percent versus 6 percent. 2. Toyota relied on identical suppliers as of Ford motor vehicles and Mercedes.   3. Easy access on the internet that may cause imitation on each competitor’s latest idea.     V. Areas of Consideration |                                 |Production & operation          ......

Words: 1070 - Pages: 5

suiv. → | Read Essay | 2016❯