Utopia or Dystopia? Swift

In: English and Literature

Submitted By caroalpekas
Words 637
Pages 3
Carolina Alarcón Marín Utopia and Dystopia in: “Gulliver’s Travels” Book 4 by Jonathan Swift

“That Nation which he describes as the Seat of Virtue, and its Inhabitants as Models to all (he the lays) World reputed of his for no own Justice, and better Brain; than and Truth, are mere the Cleanliness, Fictions Temperance, Wisdom,

Houyhnhms and Yahoos deemed to have no more Existence than the Inhabitants of Utopia”.1

In the voyage to the country of the Houyhnhms, portrays a society in which the qualities of the

Jonathan Swift characters are

remarkable and in a way impossible, in other words these astounding moral and intellectual characteristics create a sense of a utopian society in the mind of the reader, especially when comparing it to the real world and the real social schemes in which we live on. Swift’s satire in Houyhnhmland may be seen as a Utopia, but the incredible yet awkward behaviour of these creatures is completely

unnatural, and therefore it creates a dystopia. This utopia is believed to be plausible because of the accumulation of details the writer provides, enveloping the reader and blurring the limits between reality and imagination that have been imbedded in our minds through the socialization process.
“...He looked upon us as a sort of animals to whose share he could not conjecture, some small pittance of reason had fallen, whereof we made no other use than by its assistance to aggravate our natural

Williams, Kathleen, editor. ”Anonymous criticisms of Houyhnhmland”, in “Jonathan Swift: The critical heritage”, Routledge, London, 1970, p. 97.

Carolina Alarcón Marín Midterm Essay corruptions, us...”











The superiority of the Houyhnhms is especially noticed when judging human kind, because of the way in which one of them talks about “Yahoos”…...

Similar Documents


...Dystopia Dystopia is often a society set in the future that has degraded into a repressive and controlled state, often under the control of some form of government but not always. A dystopian society can also be a planned structured society in which the conditions of life are deliberately made miserable. Some examples of these can be characterized by poverty, oppression, violence, disease, scarcity, and/or pollution for the benefit of a select minority or some unnatural societal goal. I am going to discuss how the short story “The Lottery," by Shirley Jackson and the film Demolition Man directed by Marco Brambilla exhibits dystopian. In the short story “They Lottery” the author makes a society where the town people are willing to kill each other in order to preserve a their idea of balance and success. The town in "The Lottery,” have employed what they sees as the fairest way to continue this ancient tradition. “The Lottery” is a story of misguidance and ultimate horror. The way the plot is structured takes the audience from one extreme (a very sunny, happy day) to another (a ghastly murder). The town is described as a simple and beautiful one, with children running and playing, happy to be out of school for the summer. The reader is led to believe that everything is perfect and the community is gathering for a raffle of some kind. After all, the story’s title is “The Lottery”. Lotteries have a positive connotation in most peoples’ mind. Lotteries are usually......

Words: 797 - Pages: 4


...Dystopias: Definition and Characteristics Utopia: A place, state, or condition that is ideally perfect in respect of politics, laws, customs, and conditions. Dystopia: A futuristic, imagined universe in which oppressive societal control and the illusion of a perfect society are maintained through corporate, bureaucratic, technological, moral, or totalitarian control. Dystopias, through an exaggerated worst-case scenario, make a criticism about a current trend, societal norm, or political system. Characteristics of a Dystopian Society • • • • • • • • • Propaganda is used to control the citizens of society. Information, independent thought, and freedom are restricted. A figurehead or concept is worshipped by the citizens of the society. Citizens are perceived to be under constant surveillance. Citizens have a fear of the outside world. Citizens live in a dehumanized state. The natural world is banished and distrusted. Citizens conform to uniform expectations. Individuality and dissent are bad. The society is an illusion of a perfect utopian world. Types of Dystopian Controls Most dystopian works present a world in which oppressive societal control and the illusion of a perfect society are maintained through one or more of the following types of controls: • Corporate control: One or more large corporations control society through products, advertising, and/or the media. Examples include Minority Report and Running Man. Bureaucratic control: Society is controlled by a......

Words: 327 - Pages: 2

Analysing Dystopia in Brave New World

...Analysing Dystopia in a “Brave New World” The concept of Dystopia in literature is a form of exploring various interpretations of a different world. Specifically, a dystopian text explores a domain in which a society and way of life may seem ideal (Utopia), yet within the text it is later revealed that the society remain mentally unprepared and incapable of sustaining order in their world. Most dystopian texts illustrate a world which has been resulted in the consequence of humanity and this is one of the main reasons it is regularly visited. It is a genre in which the dystopian texts frequently challenge the views and values of their current audiences. This is because they are judged and critiqued on their depiction of scenes and events that breach sensitive moral and ethical issues. What makes the genre so fascinating both to read and write is to remind ourselves of the capabilities of humanity and just how much we can impact a hypothetical world. It is also a way in which we can ponder the extremes we as a society can reach and reflect the possibilities of the very future of the human race. Another reason why the concept intrigues us is because dystopian texts are subconsciously thought to be renditions of hell. With Utopia being the impression of heaven or an ideal world, Dystopia corresponds as the opposite. These ideas are explored in Aldous Huxley’s classic dystopian piece “Brave New World” [1932]. “Brave New World” by Aldous Huxley is considered a dystopian text due...

Words: 1412 - Pages: 6


...Utopia (/juːˈtoʊpiə/) is an ideal community or society possessing highly desirable or perfect qualities. The word was coined in Greek by Sir Thomas More for his 1516 book Utopia, describing a fictional island society in the Atlantic Ocean. The term has been used to describe both intentional communities that attempt to create an ideal society, and fictional societies portrayed inliterature. It has spawned other concepts, most prominently dystopia. In many cultures, societies, and religions, there is some myth or memory of a distant past when humankind lived in a primitive and simple state, but at the same time one of perfect happiness and fulfillment. In those days, the various myths tell us, there was an instinctive harmony between humanity and nature. People's needs were few and their desires limited. Both were easily satisfied by the abundance provided by nature. Accordingly, there were no motives whatsoever for war or oppression. Nor was there any need for hard and painful work. Humans were simple and pious, and felt themselves close to the gods. According to one anthropological theory, hunter-gatherers were the original affluent society. Religious utopias can be intra-religious or inter-religious. The inter-religious utopia borders on a concept like Polyculturalism and is not deemed possible in the near future or the near-far future. Fledgling theories are generally canceled as impossible, but the ideology of God and Religion used in inter-religious utopia is commonly......

Words: 544 - Pages: 3

Dytopia vs Utopia

...similarities? Many people have described the world we live in today as a dystopia because it is flawed and filled with imperfections. A fantasy world is what’s called a utopia because it’s a perfect world. The dystopic world versus a utopic world, what are the similarities? What are the differences? The legal definition of dystopia “an imagined place or state in which everything is unpleasant or bad, typically a totalitarian or environmentally degraded one” (Webster). A dystopia is the world we currently live in because in certain parts of the world it can be very degrading and dark. Watching the news alone will give anybody a sense of despair because it’s filled with wars, people dying, and tragedy; whether it’s human induced or natural. The media is constantly buzzing with various scandals, such as corruption by people in high places. Violence has become normal and a part of everyday life, people are immune to violence and bad news. This is the real world definition of a dystopia because it does give you a sense of despair and watching the news will make you think that the world is bad and unpleasant. A utopia is the complete opposite of the dark world. It’s a place where everything is peaceful, there are no deaths, no wars, no corruption scandals, no clergy, rulers, king, or army(s). It is a completely peaceful and beautiful world; there is no need for weapons or violence of any sort like a dystopia. A utopia is the sort of world where people escape to in their minds,......

Words: 691 - Pages: 3

Utopias: Not for Us

...William Saffold Professor Caine Writing 106 Utopia/Dystopia 20 February 2012 It’s Not Worth It It is not difficult to see what it takes to have a Utopian Society. George Saunders’s world in “The Semplica-Girl Dairies” was in no way a Utopia. There was nothing but chaos from beginning to end and in all facets. However much the characters in the story tried to make everything perfect it never seemed to really work. Contrarily Forster’s “The Machine Stops” began as a Utopia and fell apart. After reading both stories, and looking at specific examples from “The Machine Stops”, I have come to the conclusion that in order to reach a true utopian society it is more important for everyone to be nourished and content with what they have rather than give everyone the opportunity to make themselves better. However, I believe that pursuing a utopia would be destructive to humanity. It would eradicate everything we know as beauty in our world. Forster grew up in this environment of working to better yourself. He was born around the beginning of the industrial revolution when trains and automobiles were blossoming. I would presume that this is when, as an intellectual, he foresaw humanity being consumed in technology. With his story he was trying to show us that relying on technology and not doing enough for ourselves can be disastrous. However, I do believe that he created a utopia. This was a typical room in Forster’s tunnels. “Imagine, if you can, a small......

Words: 977 - Pages: 4


...Final Project(Utopia) My final project will be on the stories we read in class. My project is about being different and doing your own thing . It will resemble the difference in people and show to stand up for what you believe in and show that it only takes one person to change the world. My project is with three different types of people ,the red fuzz ball is the outcast , the white fuzz balls are the same exact , and the purple fuzz ball is the authority . In the story Harrison Bergeron it states that one character is trying to put out the word about being different and the authority had stopped him and killed him. My project is similar that story but it is telling people to basically do to what you want unlike Harrison he was telling people to break different laws and remove handicaps. My project will hopefully help people understand that it's not always the coolest to be the same. What I am trying to say with in my project is that one voice and mind can hopefully change others minds and have an impact of so many minds. So that where they can all work together and let the government recognize the effort and time people put in to show that they want to be different to other people. The project does not have to be just about being different it can also show that if you stand up for what you believe you'll get farther than you would ever expect to and achieve more in life than you would just keeping quiet....

Words: 269 - Pages: 2


...despite the fact that such an ideal life has stayed in people’s mind, not too many people believe a real utopia exists. It is similar to when audiences watch a romantic movie with a perfect ending and tell themselves this can only happen on the screen where all the lines have been written and edited carefully. Without any hope for any possible alternatives, eventually, no one would strive to create a peaceful and fantasy world according to their dream. However, there is a country that is making the dream of a lot of people come true. In a recent decade, Singapore has been moving towards the idea of improving their social and economic problems through constructing the modern building projects. Needless to say, their significant achievement in economic social development has brought them opportunities to become one of the most stable economies in the world regardless of a limited space and sacred natural resources. Singapore is among the countries that has the lowest rate of unemployment, highest adequate living conditions and social pension, and fastest economic growth in Asia. Furthermore, it is also well known for the green environment and energy efficiency. Although Singapore is believed to be a clear example of how a utopian plan has improved human development, there are critics argue that its government is directing people in an oppressive setting through a so called utopia and that there is lack of innovation in a too stable economic organization. The rigid of the......

Words: 3276 - Pages: 14

Dystopia Text Set

... we were set out on the task to find a  common theme.  In an ideal situation, teachers would be able to embellish on these young adult books  by supporting them with supplemental sources. Through the use of newspaper articles, magazines,  picture books, videos, trailers and clips, and electronics our tenth grade English class will explore and  discover the theme; dystopia paired with defiance.   Dystopia literally means “ bad uptopia”.  According to the Merriam­Webster dictionary,  dystopia is defined as “an imaginary place where people lead dehumanized and often fearful lives”.  Unlike utopia, where a society is perceived to be a perfect place to reside, dystopia differs in that what  is “perfect” often causes an undesirable place to live.   Having students be able to understand these complex themes in addition to the “on the surface”  themes that exist within this young adult literature would ensure a deeper meaning/understanding of the  text for them. In addition, being able to present the idea to students in a multitude of facets helps to  differentiate learning for students. Also, students are able to gain a better understanding of what dystopia  really means when they see it being used in multiple different contexts.   This particular English 10 class is a co­taught class of twenty­five including six students with  disabilities. There are two students with autism, three with multiple disorders and one student with ......

Words: 5178 - Pages: 21


...Brian Garcia English 102 Professor Koplow October 5, 2013 In his book, Utopia, Sir Thomas More examines the crippled government system in England. He wrote Utopia in 1516, during the reign of King Henry VIII. He takes on this satire through the eyes of his fictional character Raphael Hythloday, where Utopia is described as a society that seems to be the ideal living situation for human beings.  A society far more advanced and just. Raphael believes Utopia’s greatest achievements include becoming the perfect society. As a nation that is based on rational thought, and religious tolerance. Where everything is shared, including your home, a world with great productivity for the greater good of the nation. In Utopia there is no class distinctions, no greed for money or gold, therefore crime and immoral behavior is kept to a minimum. In Utopia, there is no private property. Everything is owned by everyone and there is no need for anyone to want more that another person because everyone in the society works together to supply ample provisions for the whole community. When describing Utopia, Raphael points out many of the problems that he sees in English society.   One of the most striking examples of English social problems that Hythloday points out is the insistence of the English monarchy to emphasize class distinction. You’re either wealthy or a peasant. But he does say how can anyone “value himself because his cloth is made of a finer thread: for how...

Words: 999 - Pages: 4


...Youth in Dystopia (DRAFT) Christopher Lewis Chapman University May 21, 2014 Vadeboncoeur (2005) criticizes the age-old question: “What do you want to be when you grow up?” and explains that youth are always defined as being in the process of becoming an adult. But what happens if this question is no long applicable or even necessary? Dystopian novels remove this illusion of choice. In each of the novels I will address, all teenagers attend or participate in a ceremony whereby they transition from young adult to adult. The first series I will address is Scott Westerfield’s Uglies series, where youth undergo plastic surgery as their rite of passage. Maturation and growing up require endure body modifications to create same-ness and the perfectly pretty white race. Second, I will analyze Ally Condie’s Matched series, where social order to determined by sorters who decide vocation and spouses. All teenagers attend a ceremony where a person’s perfect match is determined by a computer program. Lastly, I will use Veronica Roth’s Divergent series to explore how the world is constructed by personality type. Youth choose to participate in factions that are determined by a psychological examination that detects a youth’s instinctual predilections when facing their fears. As readers begin to figure out the rules to this new society, they are challenged to make comparisons to their own world. We are forced to wonder whether or not, as educators, we reinforce......

Words: 3808 - Pages: 16


...Trung Vu Roxanne Ezzet Sociological Theory 375 30 April 2015 Utopia: Work in Process For as long as the human species has been living on this earth, it has always pondered with a question of whether or not a perfect place where there is forever peace, harmony, and happiness. The concept of heaven reflects this worldly desire for such dreamland. But does one have to die to live in this uncertain utopia after living morally on earth? Many argue that with the right combination of certain social and economical policies, we actually don’t have to wait till afterlife to live in an ideal society. This paper will present the classic theories and contemporary arguments circulating the essential elements of societies and from these arguments, construing what elements are most important that could be used to create an ideal society. In order to part away from the religious view that heaven can only exist in the hereafter, we try to establish a scientific explanation of how we as human beings have come to existence through the process of evolution. This theory appeals significantly to us for at least two reasons. First, it gives some of us who aren’t as religious a more satisfying validation of our origin and our destination. This view opposes Max Weber’s description of a Calvinist who always suffers great inner loneliness due to his ambiguous predestined fate. Second, the theory of evolution is in alignment with our positive and pre-established perception of progress and......

Words: 1887 - Pages: 8


...LA UTOPIA KEYNESIANA. UNA VISION GENERAL: 1936-1992 José Toro Hardy. 1992 Venezuela constituyó durante varias décadas un caso digno de estudio de hasta dónde puede llegar el “paraíso keynesiano”. Desde que el país adquiere importancia internacional como nación petrolera, se pone en evidencia un hecho de singular significación: por haber heredado de la època colonial el sistema regalista español, en Venezuela el Estado es dueño de las riquezas del subsuelo, en otras palabras, es dueño del petróleo, del hierro y de todas las riquezas mineras con las cuales la naturaleza quiso dotar al país. El súbito advenimiento de la riqueza petrolera produce una situación de características muy particulares: la existencia simultánea de un Estado rico y de una población pobre. Tal situación se hizo cada vez más evidente después de la década de los treinta y, en la medida en que se incrementaban los ingresos petroleros, aunque el nivel de vida de la población aumentaba en forma acelerada, el enriquecimiento del Estado crecía en términos aún mucho más acelerados. Así la característica resaltante a partir de la década de los cuarenta ha sido la de un Estado a la vez opulento y torpe, que intenta promover el desarrollo económico del país en base a actuaciones masivas aunque espasmódicas y poco coherentes, siguiendo un modelo de actuación por “el lado de la demanda”. A pesar de todas las críticas que pudieran hacérsele, los resultados de tales acciones han......

Words: 7288 - Pages: 30

Jonathan Swift

...Jonathan Swift 1. Swift wrote "A Modest Proposal" under a pseudonym, so who is the speaker here? The speaker is a Protestant and a member of the Irish upper class. 2. Discuss the tone of the piece. Pull examples from the text to support your discussion. Swift showed disgust for the people who would rather beg than take care of themselves. He says, “These mothers instead of being able to work for their honest livelihood, are forced to employ all their time in strolling to beg sustenance for their helpless infants who, as they grow up, either turn thieves for want of work, or leave their dear native country, to fight for the Pretender in Spain, or sell themselves to the Barbados.” 3. As you know, effective argumentation appeals to logic (logos), ethics (ethos) and emotions (pathos). Please discuss how Swift uses all three appeals and how these tools impact his purpose. Swift appeals to logic by stating the issue at hand. He also appeals to logic by asking why it is the public’s responsibility to take care of these needy families. Swift appeals to pathos and ethos through the diction he uses when describing the problem. He wants the situation to change but he wants it to change for every party. 4. Explain the irony in Swift’s title, "A Modest Proposal." The title is ironic because the proposal is anything but modest. Swift presets an outrageous solution to an ongoing problem. His proposal calls attention to this problem in an extremely eye-catching way. He......

Words: 932 - Pages: 4

Dystopia - Divergent

...Dystopia – Divergent At the age of 16, the children have to take a psychological test, which indicates their best-suited faction. Later on, they’re allowed to choose any faction as their permanent group at the Choosing Ceremony. Is this our future community? And is this the best way to control the population? “Divergent” is a movie where people are divided into distinct factions based on their human virtues. This dystopia is a disguise of their problems of the future and it only gets worst. It may take places in the future but it seems like something that could happen in out time. We’re not too close to what is happing in “Divergent”. We’re slowly becoming a society who is divided into certain groups. Rich, poor, in-between people who don’t really know have to put themselves. But will the world like “Divergent” help the population or make even worse? In some way, it could really help people who don’t know what to do with their life, and here would a test really help them and guide them into a life that fits perfectly for you. But on the other hand, it could really end with a totally mess and totally chaos. If people don’t fit into the test and there come a difference result than expected, the government could take all the people that didn’t make it in the test, like they should do, and kill them. Only because they didn’t fit in the society that they created. It would make them question the government and it would in a revolution only because it would frustrate......

Words: 617 - Pages: 3

Misfits Serie TV Streaming Download | Dragon Ball Z: Plan to Eradicate Saiyans Episode 2 English Subbed | Call of Heroes