We Were Soldiers vs. Platoon

In: Historical Events

Submitted By almousa
Words 1075
Pages 5
We Were Soldiers vs. Platoon

After watching both of these films I noticed how combat was portrayed in the movie Platoon was different from the movie we were soldiers In the movie we were soldiers it was portrayed around several different officers it was focused on them and how they carried out their mission and how they took care of their men also they showed how on a platoon level and squad level were able to follow the battalion commander on the battlefield some example of the officers such as Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore, Sergeant Major Basil L. Plumley EST. However you tend to lose track of the different officers such as Lt. Herrick that charged up the hill and leads his platoon after a scout and then got himself shoot and his platoon sergeant shoot also and then it focuses the action around Sergeant Ernie Savage how assumes command of what’s left of his platoon after almost being slaughtered and calls in artillery and uses the cover of night to keep the Vietnamese from over-running their small defensive position.

In the movie Platoon the movie really centered on the enlisted man the officers were not seen in the movie a lot like we were soldiers and the officers did not to be takecare of their men and in the movie as much as we were soldiers it mainly focused on that one platoon or the squad of soldiers, the interaction between the members of the squad, the squad leader and the platoon sergeant within just that squad

I believe that one of the most important differents I have noticed is the era of the movies where made in. The movie we were soldiers was made in the era of 1965 the Battle of Ia Drang . In 1965 it was the beginning of the war for the United States of America and also begins in America and lets us see the characters with their families, their wives and children, instantly granting them greater depth and therefore…...

Similar Documents

Platoon Sgt

...PLATOON SERGEANT 28 JULY 2011 UNCLASSIFIED Abstract Being a platoon sergeant is one of the greatest positions a Non-Commissioner Officer (NCO) can achieve in the course of their career. Leading and mentoring young NCOs and Soldiers is a privilege, but can be a challenge. This paper will cover the events of my first Platoon sergeant duty while my platoon was deployed to the National Training Center (NTC) although not assigned but a fill-in. My time as a platoon sergeant has given me insight and experience I will need in the near future. Table of Contents Abstract……………………………………………………………………….1 Introduction…………………………………………………………………..2 Description of Events…....................................................................................3 Lessons Learned/ Conclusion…………………………………………………4 Introduction As a Staff Sergeant in charge of a Command Post Node (CPN) section of 35 Soldiers my leadership is tested on a daily basis. When 67th Expeditionary Signal Battalion was tasked with providing 1 Joint Network Node (JNN) and 3 CPN teams to support 329 Field Artillery Battalion out of Mississippi in a rotation to the National Training Center (NTC). Everyone knew that slice element would come from 1st platoon. Since my Advanced Leadership Course (ALC) school was during the rotation I was left off the roster and positioned as a stay back. My platoon sergeant, platoon leader and 22 Soldiers were selected for the mission. During their 2 week mission......

Words: 560 - Pages: 3

Super Soldiers

...about one of science fictions classic conspiracy theories, Super Soldiers. When I say Super Soldiers, I mean the kinds that were genetically enhance. I have found that when someone hears “super soldiers’ their minds automatically go to Captain America or Master Chief from the Halo game series. Captain America started as a small lanky soldier that gotten injected with some type of serum that turns him in to the perfect solider. Master Chief taken from his family as a child and was train for eight years before scientist started their genetic testing. Is the military trying to make their own Captain America and Master Chief with a few extra abilities? If so, who is leading the testing and what types of powers are they trying to give to our soldiers? To try to answer these questions I had to start with where did this conspiracy stemmed from. The Beginning of the End by Micheal T. Snyder has led me to the DARPA (the defense advanced research projects agency). Let us have a quick insight into this agency. The DARPA is an agency of the United States Department of Defense that is responsible for the development of new technologies for military use. Established in 1958 their original mission was to prevent technological surprises for example the launch of Sputnik. Over the years, the mission has expanded from preventing surprises to making technological surprises of our own. Could they be talking about super soldiers? Is it possible that this agency is not just working on......

Words: 1443 - Pages: 6

Soldier

...19 July 2012 The Joy of becoming a Soldier     This essay will tell you how to become a soldier starting at the Military Entrance Processing Station (MEPS) all the way to Advanced Individual Training (AIT). The MEP station is where your life changes from being your name to a number. Basic Combat Training (BCT) is just the start of the never ending training. As a soldier your mind to places it never been and put your body in positions it never seen. Becoming a soldier you become part of something more than just yourself. The first step to becoming a soldier is going through the MEP station. The MEP station is where you enter into a new life, where you last name becomes your first name. At the MEP station you take the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery (ASVAB) test. The importance of the ASVAB is to determine if an individual has the mental capacity to enlist into the military and to assist the branch of their choice to find a Military Occupational Specialty (MOS) that you are mentally capable of doing. This test can either be done on paper or computer. The ASVAB is a group of test that the Department of Defense established (DoD). The test consists of 9 timed subtests such as, word knowledge (WK), mathematics knowledge (MK), general science (GS), mechanical comprehension (MC), and electronics information (EI). Once your in-processing is complete at MEPs, you will prepare yourself to leave for BCT. Basic Combat training is the initial training......

Words: 514 - Pages: 3

We Were Soldiers vs. Platoon

...We Were Soldiers vs. Platoon After watching both of these films I noticed how combat was portrayed in the movie Platoon was different from the movie we were soldiers In the movie we were soldiers it was portrayed around several different officers it was focused on them and how they carried out their mission and how they took care of their men also they showed how on a platoon level and squad level were able to follow the battalion commander on the battlefield some example of the officers such as Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore, Sergeant Major Basil L. Plumley EST. However you tend to lose track of the different officers such as Lt. Herrick that charged up the hill and leads his platoon after a scout and then got himself shoot and his platoon sergeant shoot also and then it focuses the action around Sergeant Ernie Savage how assumes command of what’s left of his platoon after almost being slaughtered and calls in artillery and uses the cover of night to keep the Vietnamese from over-running their small defensive position. In the movie Platoon the movie really centered on the enlisted man the officers were not seen in the movie a lot like we were soldiers and the officers did not to be takecare of their men and in the movie as much as we were soldiers it mainly focused on that one platoon or the squad of soldiers, the interaction between the members of the squad, the squad leader and the platoon sergeant within just that squad I believe that one of the......

Words: 1075 - Pages: 5

We Were Soldiers

...War is a military response to a political situation. War and the battles which comprise those wars are often recorded in history, and those wars seem to be embedded into the human condition. Plato said, "Only the dead have seen the end of war." So as long as humans are around, there will be war, and therefore, people to tell the stories of the wars and the battles that are part of our history. The broad specter of war is often recorded as sterilized and impersonal narration dealing with politics, strategies and reasoning to explain the how and the why of battles. Such accounts are often written by historians that were not present at the battle or were safely experiencing it from a safe remote command center far from the killing. "We Were Soldiers Once...And Young" is a historical biography written by retired Lieutenant General Hal Moore and UPI Reporter Joe Galloway that recalls the events of the first major battle of the Vietnam War. The battle took place in the Ia Drang Valley between November 14 and November 18, 1965 at two landing zones northwest of Plei Me in the central Highlands of South Vietnam (approximately 35 miles south-west of Pleiku). The battle derives its name from the Drang River which runs through the valley northwest of Plei Me, in which the engagement took place. "Ia" means "river" in the local Montagnard language. The battle was fought between the US 7'th Cavalry's newly established Air Mobile forces and a mixture of Viet-Cong guerilla's and highly......

Words: 2679 - Pages: 11

Drones, Ethics, and the Armchair Soldier

...Drones, Ethics, and the Armchair Soldier This is an article by the philosopher John Kaag about how the military is dealing with the changes in today’s environment with military warfare and the affects it has on the ground pilots that are driving drones to eliminate targets and terrorists. 10 years ago the Iraq invasion was a remote control game for the soldiers, very similar to how we use our remote controls for channel surfing on the TV or video games today. Many people use remote controls to play games, shoot animals, and blow up buildings to entertain themselves. The military uses similar remote controls to direct and deliver devastating military assaults against enemies and terrorists. Today the operations of the traditional chain of command is similar to writing directions for robots but without having to think about ethics behind it. Now soldiers do not have to be carrying pounds of gear while fighting and fearing for their lives, instead they do their jobs sitting down, they have something in common with philosophers who do their job sitting down. John quoted, “For the first time in history, soldiers have something in common with philosophers: they can do their jobs sitting down.” This provides the remote control soldier additional time and ability to think about how they will use a drone to eliminate a target. Soldiers today need to work their way through arriving at the logical answer of their orders and decisions while working through existential......

Words: 1225 - Pages: 5

The Deer Hunter vs We Were Soldiers

...Page 1 English 101 Sec 80655 4 April 2014 The Deer Hunter vs. We were Soldiers: The Evolution of War in Films In The Deer Hunter directed by Michael Cimino and We were Soldiers directed by Randall Wallace, both have plots that take place during the Vietnam War, involve the military, societal changes, and familial bonds. The message of each film essentially is sacrifice. The Deer Hunter and We were Soldiers use a group of three protagonists to convey its theme of sacrifice. When we take a closer look at them though we can see past the explosions and carnage that accompany most epic war films and see how war is depicted in a changing society. Society has dramatically changed since the post-Vietnam era of the 1970’s when The Deer Hunter was made, to the ultra patriotic times of an immediate post- 9/11 era when We were Soldiers was made . By demonstrating the differences between these films in the way that the military, society and family are depicted we see an evolvement of the way war is portrayed on film. First let’s take a look at the way the military is portrayed in The Deer Hunter. Having been made in a time of post-Vietnam The Deer Hunter depicts the military with the attitude of the times, in that the military was not looking out for our nation’s and soldier’s best interests. Cimino‘s depiction is of an army made up of men drafted into service. They are fulfilling their duty and making the......

Words: 1559 - Pages: 7

We Were Soldiers

...log drills and litter runs. While this is being conducted I will monitor each soldier and identify specific problems that need to be worked on and adjust the training schedule accordingly. As far as the soldiers that are overweight they would conduct physical training with the platoon as well as take part in special population PT the same day. This would be emplaced to help push those soldiers to get within standards in accordance with AR600-9 that much faster. The overweight soldiers need a special separate plan to get where they need to be, but taking away from physical training that is imperative to the mission is a problem. That is why we would initiate a special population program at a different time. If I was a squad leader that inherits a squad that has overweight issues, I will first schedule an appointment for my squad to see a dietician. Once I have all the results and recommendations from the doctor, I will come up with the best course of action for my squad to make them lean mean fighting machines. I will monitor their diets and come up with a strenuous physical training plan that will prepare them for the harsh terrains in Afghanistan. I will assess their previous PT cards to see who the most physically fit soldiers within my squad are so I will know if I had to start off at beginner’s level or if we can go at full force. My PT plan will consist of PRT, Cross fit, and Ruck Marching. We will conduct PRT in the morning after accountability formation because PRT......

Words: 911 - Pages: 4

Platoon

...Courage” The story is about a young Union soldier named Henry whose courage is very questionable and during the battle he redeems himself and finds his courage. The story is fictional written by Stephen Crane who was a Union soldier during the Civil War but never saw combat. Though the book was not accepted in the United States when first written it got very high acclaims in England afterwards the U.S. public gave the book their approval and book sales rose. Everyone thought that Crane was an experienced writer which he was not. One evening when Henry was on guard duty a confederate soldier on the other side of the river told him to get out of the moonlight or otherwise would receive a little red badge. Henry understood this to mean a gunshot wound and retreated into the shadows and thanked the Confederate soldier. The young man upon hearing they may be going into battle describes his fears as he writes his father and explains that he hopes to make him proud in the upcoming battle. He then asks his father to let his mother know gently if he should fall in battle. The story some say was the Battle of Chancellorsville. When the marching orders are given to the solders Henry is fearful he will not hold the line as described in the orders. Upon the first charge he does hold and then on the second charge he turns and runs. He then runs into a group of wounded soldiers walking away from the battle. When one of the wounded soldiers asks him where he is injured......

Words: 843 - Pages: 4

Movie Review - We Were Soldiers

... Movie Review We Were Soldiers Burt Thomas Liberty University CRIS303 – B01 Movie Review We Were Soldiers We Were Soldiers is a movie written and directed by Randall White. It is based on a book, We Were Soldiers Once…and Young: Ia Drang, the Battle That Changed the War in Vietnam by Lt. Col. Hal Moore and Joe Galloway. It details the account of both men, as well as the men under Moore’s command during the battle of the Ia Drang Valley. The battle takes place early in the Viet Nam War and the movie provides a historical, as well as dramatic recount of the battle and the lives of the men who fought it. Movie Synopsis A narrator begins the movie by retelling the story of the French involvement in the early days of the Viet Nam War. There is a graphic depiction of violence as the French soldiers are killed, and the viewer is briefly introduced to Lt. Col. Nguyen Huu An. Lt. Col An would later command the North Vietnamese Army (NVA) soldiers during the battle with Moore’s soldiers. Eleven years later, the army is establishing an air cavalry division and Lt. Col. Moore is selected to command them. Mel Gibson, in the role of Lt. Col. Moore enlists the help of Maj. Bruce “Snake” Crandall, played by Greg Kinnear. Crandall’s crew of pilots is made up of a motley group of men and his pilots and equipment are considered to be some of the best in the Army at the time. The division is redesignated as the 7th Cavalry, and Moore notes the irony in its designation - this is the...

Words: 1338 - Pages: 6

Creativity vs Activity: Transforming Leisure as We Know It

...Creativity vs Activity: Transforming Leisure as We Know It In “Doing Nothing is Something”, by Anna Quindlen, she expresses her concern about the extent of scheduling parents do for their children. She argues that children have lost the sense of what it’s like to have nothing to do, because their parents have enabled them to perpetually be busy. By scheduling every minute of a child’s day, there is no chance for downtime. In order for children to find creativity and explore it they must be allowed time to do nothing. Downtime allows imagination, ingenuity and inventiveness of children to become better thinkers. The current society has become so fast paced, and filled with activity we have lost the importance of what leisure brings, balance. Creativity best presents itself when there is downtime, it allows one to expand and form ideas within their own minds, which are unlimited. As children, once schoolwork and chores are done, there should be play time, when they can just be kids. Children need time to create moments like fighting giants, and watching dragons attack castles. The reality is, they are fighting an old tree, long past dead with a stick and watching clouds pass in the sky. These are just a couple examples of how creativity and imagination can happen, and should continue. Quindlen writes, “I don’t believe you can write poetry, or compose music, or become and actor without downtime, and plenty of it, a hiatus that passes for boredom but is really the quiet......

Words: 886 - Pages: 4

The Quantity vs. Quality in Special Forces

...The Quantity vs. Quality in Special Forces Review of Literature Carlos Falcón Saldaña MBA 525 Abstract Special Forces (SF), or more comely called “Green Berets” have a long and prestigious historical roots that stem from the elite Army formations of World War II and the Office of Strategic Service (OSS). In fiscal year 2015, the Army is looking for about 3,000 candidates to attend Special Forces Assessment and Selection, officials from the Special Operations Recruiting Battalion (SORB) said. Recruiters are seeking about 2,000 active-duty enlisted soldiers, 1,540 new recruits (for the 18X program), and about 400 active-duty officers. (Tan, 2015) With the US Army’s draw down and many SF Soldiers getting out for various reasons (Retirement, Medical Discharge, Career Opportunities) the US Army had to do something and something quick to keep the number of SF soldiers in the ranks. The re-birth of an old program seem to be the solution for this problem. This paper will identify the Quantity vs. Quality in Special Forces and in the SF Soldiers and identify why this program was “Moth-Balled” in the first place. Chapter I Introduction Introduction Special Forces (SF), Green Berets were first formed from the Office of Strategic Service (OSS) back from WWII. The OSS was formed in World War II to gather strategic intelligence and conduct operations behind enemy lines in support of resistance groups in Europe and the Far East. After the war, individuals such as Colonel......

Words: 4222 - Pages: 17

Summary of Platoon

...Platoon In the movie Platoon from 1986, the battles of the Vietnam War are shown. In the movie we follow the young and inexperienced soldier Chris Taylor, who is going through a lot of struggles being in the fields. When we get to know the soldiers one by one, the movie shows how the relationships between the soldiers are not always equal and very solidary. In the beginning the platoon is separated by three groups; the black ones, the young and new ones and the experienced, who leads the agenda in the platoon. Later on the two sergeants Barnes and Elias disagrees about how the battle against the Vietnamese should proceed. This leads to Sgt. Barnes killing Sgt. Elias illegally. The death of Sgt. Elias leads to an even bigger division in the platoon, because the soldiers is forced to “choose which side they’re on” and what really happened with Sgt. Elias. The final battle in the movie is a long and intense part of the movie. Everything becomes very chaotic between the soldiers and the battle becomes a fight for your own survival, where you can’t trust anyone. The battle shows how many soldiers both Vietnamese and American, who didn’t make it out of the violent bloodbath. During the movie Chris Taylor has always tolerated everything that has been decided around him, even though he didn’t agree. At the end of the movie he put his foot dowm and killed Sgt. Barnes as a symbol of justice for Sgt. Elias. Chris Taylor survives and is flown away from the war. When he is sitting in......

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

“We Were the People Who Were Not in the Papers. We Lived in the Blank White Spaces at the Edges of Print…We Lived in the Gaps Between the Stories.” Discuss the Writers’ Exploration of Female Passivity.

...“We were the people who were not in the papers. We lived in the blank white spaces at the edges of print…We lived in the gaps between the stories.” Discuss the writers’ exploration of female passivity. William Shakespeare, Margaret Atwood and Alfred Tennyson all present female passivity as a deep-rooted, normalised concept that is engrained into the framework of relationships, society and government. Whilst this is seen to remain from the 1600s all the way to the 1980s, there are subtle differences in the portrayal of, attempted reasoning behind and methods used to enforce this passivity, highlighted through analysis of language, structure and context. The writers symbolically use setting to explore links between different aspects of female passivity. Tennyson links public and private spaces and their promotion of female passivity to illustrate societal as well as psychological and domestic examples of passivity. In Mariana, the “rusted” and “crusted” atmosphere of decay is representative of Mariana’s psychological deterioration and the stagnant “blacken’d waters” and “moated grange” act as an obstruction to her integration with the outside patriarchal world. This reflects the wider Victorian attitude regarding the home as “the centre of virtue and the proper life for women” and brings to light the impact that passivity in the greater context of society has on the role she plays in her private relationship. This idea of external influences is echoed much less......

Words: 3969 - Pages: 16

We Were the Mulvaneys

...After completing the book, We Were The Mulvaneys, by Joyce Carol Oates, most of the questions I had about the book as a whole, were answered. However, I was left with a few unanswered questions in my mind. I also believe our TAI fits better with the second half of this book. There are more times in the book, where the places they live or don't live influence their lives. Before reading this half of the book, I was very uncertain about how it would fit in with the first half; but after reading it, I believe it fits very well and enjoyed it a lot. During the second half, many smaller problems occur for the family rather than the major one in the first half. It briefly follows each of the siblings lives, except for Marianne, where it goes very in-depth with her life. Mike Jr. has joined the marines, and now has a wife and two kids, and is very happy. Patrick has had many different occupations, but has finally settled down to teach children and also has a woman in his life. Marianne has also had many different jobs, because she does not want to stay in one place for too long. Finally, Judd, who has just recently moved out of his parent's house, is a newspaper editor in the town he lives in. Sadly, Michael Sr. passed away from cancer. Corinne now lives with a friend and they run their antique shop together. The power of place was much more evident in this part of the book. I believe this because of all the different places the family members have lived. The most......

Words: 907 - Pages: 4

Kenan Thompson | Samsung Galaxy J4- 5.5, 32GB ROM, 2GB RAM, 13MP+5MP Dual Sim- Black.. -44% KSh 14,999 KSh 26,999 (63) Buy now | El mundo es suyo BluRay 1080p